Oral Gift in Pakistan: Found 17 Years Later, Daughters Still Won

Oral gift in Pakistan case where three daughters kept their inheritance share
Three daughters, two old gift deeds and one question: where was the proof of the hiba?

That is what three daughters from Arifwala, District Pakpattan, discovered in 2009. Their father’s land had passed to other relatives through gift deeds of 1992 and 1993, defended in court as an oral gift in Pakistan that was later recorded. They sued. Sixteen years after that discovery, the Supreme Court refused to disturb their win.

The ruling is reported as 2026 SCMR 587. It answers the questions families ask most: Is an oral gift (zabani hiba) valid? Who has to prove it? Does a mutation (intiqal) make someone the owner? Can daughters still go to court after many years? Below, we explain the judgment in plain words and then give practical checklists for both sides.

Table of Contents

Judgment at a Glance: 2026 SCMR 587

PointDetail
CourtSupreme Court of Pakistan
BenchJustice Shahid Bilal Hassan and Justice Miangul Hassan Aurangzeb
Case numberC.P.L.A. No. 990 of 2022
Case titleAbdul Majeed and others v. Mst. Khalida Bibi (deceased) through L.Rs. and others
Citation2026 SCMR 587
Date of decision24 June 2025
Order challengedLahore High Court order of 25.01.2022 in C.R. No. 3308 of 2022
Property244 Kanals of farmland, Chak No. 26/E.B., Tehsil Arifwala, District Pakpattan
Laws involvedSpecific Relief Act 1877 (ss. 42, 54, 55); Punjab Land Revenue Act 1967 (s. 42); Qanun-e-Shahadat Order 1984 (Art. 129(g)); Limitation Act 1908 (Art. 120); Constitution, Art. 185(3)
Result in one lineLeave to appeal refused, so the daughters’ decree from the trial court stands

IRAC Analysis: How the Court Tested the Gift

IRACWhat it means in this case
IssueDid the alleged donees prove a valid gift, and the mutations based on it, that cut three daughters out of their father’s land? Was the daughters’ suit time-barred?
RuleA valid gift needs offer, acceptance and delivery of possession. Their details must be pleaded and proved. No evidence can go beyond the pleadings. The gift and the mutation must each be proved separately. Withheld evidence invites an adverse presumption under Article 129(g).
AnalysisThe written statement gave no details of the offer, the acceptance, the place or the witnesses. Key witnesses were never produced. No reason was shown for leaving the daughters out. Limitation had been rightly decided by three courts.
ConclusionNo illegality in the concurrent findings. Petition dismissed and leave refused.

The Story Behind 244 Kanals in Arifwala

Imdad Ali owned 244 Kanals of farmland at Chak No. 26/E.B., Tehsil Arifwala. According to the plaint, he died about 10 to 12 years before the suit, leaving three daughters and two sons. By inheritance (wirasat), the daughters claimed 104 Kanals and 11 Marlas together.

That figure fits the usual Islamic rule where a son takes twice a daughter’s share. With two sons and three daughters, the estate splits into 7 parts, and 3 of those parts come to about 104 Kanals 11 Marlas.

The daughters described themselves as simple, illiterate and parda-observing women. Their brothers held the land and gave them a share of the produce, so they never checked the revenue record. In law, they said, they still had constructive possession as co-owners.

What the Daughters Found at the Patwari’s Office

On 2 May 2009, the daughters went to the Halqa Patwari for a copy of the record of rights (fard). They needed it to apply for a loan from Zarai Taraqiati Bank. Instead of a routine copy, they learnt that the land had already been transferred away and that, on paper, they were no longer owners.

Two Gift Deeds, Two Mutations and Two Bank Loans

DocumentNumberDate or detail
Gift deed162/127.02.1992
Gift deed901/121.09.1993
Gift mutation83527.02.1992
Gift mutation88419.01.1994
Mortgage mutations (Zarai Taraqiati Bank, Arifwala)993 and 1650Loans of Rs. 334,400 and Rs. 332,800

The daughters called both gift deeds a fraud, prepared only to cut them out of their inherited shares. They said the deeds and the mutations were void and could not bind them.

How the Case Moved From Trial Court to Supreme Court

Case path from trial court to Supreme Court in the daughters' gift dispute
StageForumDateResult
Suit for declaration with perpetual and mandatory injunctionTrial court08.05.2021Suit decreed for the daughters
First appeal No. 32-ADJ-2021First appellate court08.12.2021Appeal dismissed
Civil Revision No. 3308 of 2022Lahore High Court25.01.2022Revision dismissed
C.P.L.A. No. 990 of 2022 under Article 185(3)Supreme Court24.06.2025Leave refused

So the alleged donees lost at every level. By the time the case reached the Supreme Court, three courts had already found against them on the facts.

What Each Side Argued

The daughters (plaintiffs) said they became owners the moment their father died. They had trusted their brothers, only found out in 2009, and called the gift deeds and mutations a fraud and misrepresentation.

The alleged donees (defendants, later petitioners) defended the gift and the mutations on both facts and law. They pleaded that the transaction was valid and genuine. In the Supreme Court, their counsel argued the petition, while no one appeared for the daughters.

The reported order does not list the petitioners’ detailed grounds, so we do not guess them here.

The Evidence That Never Reached the Witness Box

Six witnesses never produced to prove the disputed gift deed and mutations

The petitioners’ biggest problem was not what they said. It was who they did not bring to court. To prove the alleged registered gift deed and the mutations, they did not produce:

Missing witnessWhy that witness mattered
Stamp vendorCould confirm who bought the stamp paper, and when
Scribe (deed writer)Could explain who gave instructions and what was written
Marginal witnessesSigned the deed as witnesses of its execution
Identifying witnessIdentified the parties before the Sub-Registrar
Sub-RegistrarRegistered the deed and recorded who appeared
Patwari and revenue officialsEntered and sanctioned the mutations

Each of these people could have backed the donees’ story. None of them stepped into the witness box.

The Law on Oral Gift in Pakistan (Hiba)

A gift, or hiba, is a transfer of property during the owner’s lifetime without any payment. Muslim law allows it to be made by words alone, which is what people mean by an oral gift in Pakistan. But the law also asks for strict proof, because a gift can quietly wipe out the shares of other heirs.

The 3 Essentials: Offer, Acceptance, Possession

Three essentials of an oral hiba: offer, acceptance and delivery of possession

The Supreme Court repeated the settled rule in paragraph 4. A valid gift needs three things:

  1. Offer (declaration): the owner clearly says he is giving the property now, without payment.
  2. Acceptance: the person receiving it accepts, openly or by conduct.
  3. Delivery of possession: control of the property actually passes to the donee.

If any one is missing, there is no completed gift. For a step-by-step look at written gifts, see our guide on gift deed (hiba nama) law in Pakistan.

Does a Muslim’s Gift Need a Registered Deed?

Under section 123 of the Transfer of Property Act 1882, a gift of land generally needs a registered instrument. Section 129 of the same Act keeps the rules of Muslim law on gifts intact. That is why an oral gift in Pakistan between Muslims can be valid without a registered deed, once its three essentials are proved.

This case adds a warning. The donees here also relied on registered gift deeds, yet still lost. Paper or registration does not replace proof of the actual transaction.

Where Mutation (Intiqal) Fits In

Under section 42 of the Punjab Land Revenue Act 1967, a person who acquires land by gift, sale or inheritance must report it to the Patwari, who enters it in the register of mutations. A Revenue Officer then decides whether to sanction it.

Section 42(7) adds safeguards. Apart from inheritance, registered deeds and court decrees, the order must be made in the presence of the person whose right is affected, identified by two respectable persons such as Lambardars. Section 42(8) says the inquiry should take place in the common assembly of the village. Our guide to inheritance mutation in Pakistan explains the process further.

Why the Supreme Court Refused Leave: 5 Reasons

The order is short, but every line carries a lesson. These are the five reasons the petitioners failed.

1. The Written Statement Was Silent on Key Details

The court read the donees’ reply to paragraph 2 of the plaint. It found no description of when Imdad Ali made the offer, how the petitioners accepted, where it happened, or who was present. These facts must be pleaded and proved, the court said, relying on Mst. Ramzanu Bibi v. Ibrahim (2025 SCMR 955).

2. Evidence Cannot Go Beyond Pleadings

The petitioners’ witnesses did not state those details in court either. Even if they had, it would not help. The Supreme Court repeated that a party cannot lead evidence beyond its pleadings. A case must be built in the written statement first and then proved through reliable evidence.

3. Gift and Mutation Need Separate Proof

Gift and mutation need separate proof under Pakistani land and evidence law

Paragraph 5 sets out a two-part test that every gift claimant should remember:

  • Part one: prove the oral gift itself, with all three essentials, through cogent and reliable evidence.
  • Part two: prove the mutation separately, under the Land Revenue Act 1967 and its Rules, and under the Qanun-e-Shahadat Order 1984.

The petitioners failed at the very first part. A sanctioned mutation could not fill the hole left by an unproved gift.

4. Silent Witnesses Triggered Article 129(g)

The stamp vendor, scribe, marginal witnesses, identifying witness, Sub-Registrar, revenue officials and Patwari were all left out. The court called this withholding the best available evidence. Under Article 129(g) of the Qanun-e-Shahadat Order 1984, a court may presume that such witnesses would not have supported the party who withheld them.

5. No Reason Was Given for Excluding the Daughters

Why would a father give his land away and leave his own daughters with nothing? The petitioners never pleaded or proved a reason, such as affection or reward for long service. The court noted that “it is rare for a gift to be made without some reason(s)” (para 5).

Who Must Prove an Oral Gift in Pakistan?

The person who benefits from the gift. The land admittedly belonged to Imdad Ali, so it was inheritable property. On his death, it passed to all his legal heirs. Anyone claiming that a gift took some heirs’ shares away carries a heavy burden to prove it.

The court added that the donees could not win by pointing at gaps in the daughters’ evidence. In the court’s words, “they had to stand on their own legs” (para 6). They had to state the date, time and place of the gift and the names of the witnesses present. They did neither.

Was the Suit Time-Barred? The Limitation Answer

Many heirs fear that a challenge to an oral gift in Pakistan dies after a few years. Here, it did not. The Supreme Court said all three courts below had rightly dealt with limitation. It relied on Ramzanu Bibi, where a suit for declaration of title was placed under Article 120 of the Limitation Act 1908, which gives six years from when the right to sue accrues.

The key point in that case was this: a declaratory suit to establish title is a continuing right, alive as long as the plaintiff still has rights in the property. Here, the daughters said they learnt of the gift deeds on 2 May 2009, and the courts accepted that their claim was in time.

Still, do not treat this as permission to wait. Each limitation question depends on its own facts, so act as soon as you discover a suspicious entry.

Final Decision of the Supreme Court

In paragraph 8, the court found no illegality in the High Court’s order or in the concurrent judgments of the trial and first appellate courts. The petition was dismissed and leave to appeal was refused. In practical terms, the trial court’s decree in favour of the daughters stands.

What the Court Did and Did Not Decide

The court decidedThe court did not decide
The alleged donees failed to plead and prove offer, acceptance, place and witnessesThat every gift to sons is invalid. A proved gift during life remains lawful
Gift and mutation must be proved independentlyAny criminal case for fraud or forgery
Withheld witnesses justified a presumption under Article 129(g)The fate of the two bank mortgages, which the order does not discuss
No reason was shown for excluding the daughtersA full appeal on merits, because leave itself was refused
The suit was within limitation, as the courts below heldThe exact wording of the written statement, which is not reproduced in the reported text

What This Judgment Means for Pakistani Families

For daughters and sisters: a gift mutation in the record is not the final word. If the person relying on it cannot prove the offer, acceptance and possession with full details, the courts can protect your share. Our guide on daughters’ inheritance rights in Pakistan explains your share in more detail.

For anyone relying on an oral gift in Pakistan: your claim must be specific from day one. Date, time, place, witnesses and the reason for the gift belong in your pleadings, and the right witnesses belong in the witness box.

For a father who truly wants to gift property: it is lawful, but do it openly. Use a registered deed, independent witnesses and a mutation sanctioned in public, hand over real possession, and keep a record of why the gift is being made.

Not every oral gift fails. In 2026 SCMR 929, the Supreme Court accepted an earlier oral gift because the supporting evidence was strong. Read that contrast in how an earlier oral hiba defeated a later deed.

Claiming an Oral Gift in Pakistan? Proof Checklist

If you are the donee, or defending a gift made in your favour, check these points before the case starts:

  • Plead the full story: date, time, place, the donor’s words, how you accepted, and the names of witnesses present.
  • Explain the reason for the gift, especially if other heirs were left out.
  • Prove possession with records such as khasra girdawari, crop sale receipts, tube-well or electricity bills, and lease papers.
  • If a deed exists, produce the stamp vendor, scribe, marginal witnesses, identifier and, where needed, the Sub-Registrar’s record.
  • For the mutation, produce the Patwari, the Revenue Officer’s record, the identifiers and the roznamcha entry.
  • Never rely only on the mutation, or on weaknesses in the other side’s case.

Left Out of an Inheritance? Steps for Legal Heirs

If a relative suddenly relies on an oral gift in Pakistan to claim your family land, these steps help you protect your share:

  1. Get the land record. Obtain the fard, jamabandi and mutation copies from the Arazi Record Centre. Punjab’s official land record portal is punjab-zameen.gov.pk.
  2. Get the deed. Apply for a certified copy of any gift deed from the Sub-Registrar’s office.
  3. Preserve the discovery date. Keep proof of when you first learnt of the transfer, such as a loan application or a record request.
  4. Keep proof of your share. Save receipts, messages or witnesses showing you received produce or rent from the land.
  5. Take legal advice on a suit. A civil suit for declaration with injunction is filed in the civil court where the land is situated. Plead fraud with clear particulars and ask the court to summon the revenue record.
  6. Women in Punjab have another forum. Under the Punjab Enforcement of Women’s Property Rights Act 2021, a woman deprived of her property can complain to the Ombudsperson Punjab. The Ombudsperson can seek a Deputy Commissioner’s report within 15 days and decide, preferably, within 60 days.

If your case is already in court, the Ombudsperson may ask the court to transfer it. Discuss with your lawyer which forum suits your facts.

Six practical steps for heirs left out of inheritance by a gift mutation

Common Mistakes That Sink Gift Cases

SideCommon mistakeWhy it hurts
DoneeA vague written statementMissing details cannot be added later through evidence
DoneeSkipping deed and mutation witnessesInvites an adverse presumption under Article 129(g)
DoneeLeaning only on the mutationA mutation does not prove the gift behind it
HeirWaiting years after discoveryMakes limitation arguments harder
HeirNo proof of when you found outWeakens the claim that the suit is in time
HeirSigning family papers under pressureCan be used later as consent or relinquishment

FAQs: Oral Gift in Pakistan

What is an oral gift in Pakistan?

An oral gift in Pakistan is a hiba made by spoken words, without a written deed. Under Muslim law, it is valid only when three things happen: the owner clearly offers the property, the receiver accepts it, and possession actually passes. Courts expect the date, place and witnesses to be stated and proved, especially when the gift cuts out other legal heirs.

Is an oral hiba valid without a registered deed?

Yes, for Muslims. Section 123 of the Transfer of Property Act 1882 generally requires a registered instrument for gifts of land, but section 129 saves the rules of Muslim law. So an oral hiba can be valid without registration. It still has to be proved through reliable evidence, and registration alone does not save a gift whose essentials are not proved.

Does a gift mutation prove ownership?

Not on its own. A mutation (intiqal) records a change in the revenue record. In 2026 SCMR 587, the Supreme Court said the gift and the mutation are two separate parts. The beneficiary must first prove the gift itself, then prove the mutation under the Land Revenue Act 1967 and the Qanun-e-Shahadat Order 1984.

Who has to prove an oral gift in court?

The person who benefits from it. When a gift takes away the shares of other legal heirs, the beneficiary carries a heavy burden. They must prove the offer, acceptance and delivery of possession on their own evidence. They cannot win simply by pointing at weaknesses in the heirs’ case.

Can a father gift all his land to his sons only?

A Muslim owner may gift property during his lifetime, and a proved gift is lawful. But courts look closely when daughters or other heirs are left out. The Supreme Court noted that gifts are rarely made without a reason, such as affection or long service. If no reason is pleaded and proved, the claim becomes much weaker.

Can daughters challenge a gift mutation years later?

Often, yes, but it depends on the facts. In this case, the daughters learnt of the gift deeds in 2009, and the courts held the suit was within time. The Supreme Court relied on Ramzanu Bibi, which treats a declaratory suit about title as a continuing right under Article 120. Act quickly once you discover an entry.

What did the Supreme Court decide in 2026 SCMR 587?

It refused leave to appeal on 24 June 2025 and upheld the decree for three daughters over their share of 244 Kanals in Arifwala. The alleged donees had not pleaded or proved the offer, acceptance, place or witnesses of the gift, withheld key witnesses, and gave no reason for excluding the daughters.

What if the Patwari or deed witnesses are not produced?

The court may presume their evidence would have gone against the party who withheld them. That is Article 129(g) of the Qanun-e-Shahadat Order 1984. In this case, the stamp vendor, scribe, marginal witnesses, identifier, Sub-Registrar, revenue officials and Patwari were all missing, and this badly damaged the donees’ case.

Conclusion

This case shows how much an oral gift in Pakistan must carry before a court will accept it. A father’s land had sat in the record under other names for years, backed by gift deeds and mutations. Yet the claim collapsed because nobody could say clearly when, where and before whom the gift was made, or why the daughters were left out.

For heirs, the lesson is to check the record and act fast. For donees, it is to plead every detail and bring every witness. You can find more rulings like this in our gift and hiba disputes section.

Disclaimer

This article is for legal awareness only and is not legal advice. Every case depends on its own facts, documents and evidence. For your specific matter, consult a qualified lawyer.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top