
Imagine your uncle dies. Your two brothers are named as his legal heirs in court. You and your sister are not, and nobody even asked you. That is exactly what happened in one Karachi family, and the two sisters took their uncle’s inheritance (wirasat) case to the Sindh High Court.
Their question is the one behind every search for nieces inheritance rights Pakistan Hanafi law: if the brothers inherit from their uncle, why can’t their sisters take at least half of what each brother gets?
The answer surprised many people. The court did not reject the sisters because they were women. It rejected them because of where they stood on the family tree. The deceased’s own daughter, also a woman, was fully protected. This article explains the rule, the appeal that followed, and what you should check before you make or resist a claim like this.
Table of Contents
Judgment at a Glance: 2026 CLC 120
| Point | Details |
|---|---|
| Court | High Court of Sindh at Karachi (single bench) |
| Judge | Justice Arshad Hussain Khan |
| Case | S.M.A. No. 99 of 2022, Noor Muhammad (deceased); Ms. Amna Ashfaq, petitioner |
| Citation | 2026 CLC 120 [Sindh] |
| Date of order | 6 May 2024 |
| Deceased | Died without a will on 16 March 2021 at Karachi |
| Heirs on record | Widow, one minor daughter, two sons of a predeceased brother |
| Objectors | Two daughters of the same predeceased brother (the nieces) |
| Law applied | Hanafi law of inheritance; Mulla’s Principles of Muhammadan Law, paras 61, 63, 65 and 67 |
| Result | Nieces’ objections rejected; succession application allowed |
| Later appeal | High Court Appeal No. 219 of 2024, dismissed on 30 January 2025 |
In one line, this case sets the baseline for nieces inheritance rights Pakistan Hanafi law: when Sharers and Residuaries are alive, a brother’s daughter does not inherit, even if her own brothers do.
IRAC: Why the Nieces’ Claim Failed
| IRAC | Simple Explanation |
|---|---|
| Issue | Could the daughters of the deceased’s predeceased brother inherit alongside his widow, his daughter and the brother’s sons, taking half of what each nephew takes? |
| Rule | Under Hanafi law, Sharers take their fixed shares first. Residuaries take what is left. Distant Kindred inherit only when no Sharer or Residuary is present (Mulla, para 61; PLD 2014 SC 779). |
| Analysis | The widow and the only daughter were Sharers. The brother’s sons were male relatives through a male link, so they were Residuaries. The brother’s daughters are not on the Residuary list; they are Distant Kindred. They could not join their brothers on a two-to-one basis. |
| Conclusion | The nieces got nothing in this family structure. Their objections were rejected, the application was allowed, and the appeal later failed. |
The Family Behind the Case

The deceased died in Karachi on 16 March 2021 without leaving a will. He was survived by his widow and one minor daughter. He had no son.
He had one real brother, who had died before him. That brother left two sons and two daughters. In simple words, the deceased left a widow, a daughter, two nephews (bhatijay) and two nieces (bhatijiyan).
The widow filed a Succession Miscellaneous Application in the Sindh High Court. She asked for a succession certificate and letter of administration for the deceased’s debts, securities and properties. Relying on a fatwa from Darul Uloom Karachi, she named the two nephews as legal heirs and left the nieces out.
When the nieces came to know about the case, they filed objections. They asked to be added as legal heirs and for the estate to be divided according to the share of every heir.
What the Nieces Asked the Court For
The nieces’ lawyer accepted that Muslim law has three classes of heirs: Sharers, Residuaries and Distant Kindred.
First, since the deceased had no son, grandson, father or grandfather, his brother would have taken the remainder as a Residuary. Second, because that brother had died first, his share should pass to his children, sons and daughters alike. Third, the daughters should share with the sons, each taking half of what a son takes.
He also argued that Islam guarantees women a share, and that Pakistani laws such as the Muslim Family Laws Ordinance, 1961 protect that right. He relied on 2023 MLD 1354, 2023 MLD 1357 and 2023 YLR 675.
Why the Widow Said the Nieces Had No Share
The widow’s lawyer replied that a brother’s son is a Residuary, while a brother’s daughter is Distant Kindred. Distant Kindred, he said, do not inherit at all while any Sharer or Residuary is alive.
Referring to Hadith, he added that the male relative on the father’s side takes the remainder, and the nearer relative comes before the more distant one. He relied on Waris Ali v. Rasoolan Bibi, PLD 2014 SC 779, Mst. Fatima v. Lal Khan, 2001 CLC 229, and the Darul Uloom fatwa already on the record.
The Record Before the Court
This was a succession case, so the proof was mostly documentary. The record held the fatwa and the Family Registration Certificate, which named the two nephews. Both nephews filed affidavits of no objection supporting the widow’s application.
Two independent witnesses filed supporting affidavits, and everyone appeared in person to confirm them. The petition had been published in a Karachi newspaper, the Deputy Registrar’s report was on file, and a schedule listed the properties.
Nieces Inheritance Rights Pakistan Hanafi Law: The 3 Heir Classes
Between Muslims in Pakistan, inheritance follows Muslim Personal Law under the West Pakistan Muslim Personal Law (Shariat) Application Act, 1962. For Hanafi families, courts rely heavily on Mulla’s Principles of Muhammadan Law. The judge began with its paragraph 61, which divides heirs into three classes. Every relative must be placed in a class before any fraction is calculated.
Sharers (Ashab al-Furud)
Sharers are heirs whose shares are fixed, mainly by the Qur’an. A wife, a daughter, a mother and a sister are common examples. The court classed the widow and the only daughter as Sharers. The daughter took as a Sharer because the deceased had no son.
Residuaries (Asaba)
Residuaries have no fixed share. They take whatever is left after the Sharers are paid. The court classed the two nephews as Residuaries because they are male relatives connected to the deceased through a male link, their father.
Distant Kindred (Dhawil Arham)
Distant Kindred are blood relatives who are neither Sharers nor Residuaries. The court placed the two nieces in this class. Distant Kindred are real relatives, not outsiders. They simply stand in a later queue, and that queue opens only when the earlier ones are empty.

Step by Step: How a Muslim Estate Is Divided
Paragraph 5 of the order sets out the order of distribution. Think of it as a queue: nobody in a later line is served while someone in an earlier line is still waiting.
- Pay the funeral expenses.
- Pay the deceased’s debts.
- Give effect to valid legacies (wasiyat), within legal limits.
- Give the Sharers their fixed shares.
- Give whatever remains to the Residuaries.
- Only if there are neither Sharers nor Residuaries, divide the estate among the Distant Kindred.
The court put the last step plainly: “The distant kindred are not entitled to succeed so long as there is any heir belonging to the class of sharers or residuaries.” (Para 5)

Why the “Half of the Brother’s Share” Rule Failed
Many families know one rule: a daughter gets half of what a son gets. The nieces tried to apply that rule to themselves and their brothers. The court did not accept it, and that reason is the heart of nieces inheritance rights Pakistan Hanafi law.
The two-to-one rule works only when the man and the woman are in the same class and the law joins them together. Under classical Hanafi rules, a woman inherits as a Residuary alongside her brother only in a few relationships, such as a daughter with a son or a sister with a brother. A brother’s daughter is not one of them.
So the nephews and nieces were never in the same line. The nephews stood with the Residuaries. Their sisters stood in the Distant Kindred queue, which never opened because Sharers and Residuaries were present.
The Supreme Court Rule on Male Agnates
The judge relied on Waris Ali v. Rasoolan Bibi, PLD 2014 SC 779, where the Supreme Court dealt with Qur’anic Sharers and the son of a predeceased brother. It set out two basic principles of Sunni inheritance law.
First, Qur’anic Sharers receive their prescribed shares, unless a recognised rule of exclusion removes one of them. Second, what is left goes to the nearest male agnates as Residuaries. An agnate is a relative connected to the deceased through a male link, so the son of a deceased brother is a male agnate.
The order also referred to PLD 2002 SC 741 and PLD 2004 SC 768. The path was clear: the widow and daughter first, the nephews next, and no room left for the nieces.
What Each Relative Got: A Simple Illustration
The reported order says who inherits but does not write out the fractions. Here is how the usual Hanafi fractions work for this family. Treat it as an illustration only; a real division must be checked against the full record, debts and legacies.
| Heir | Class | Usual Hanafi share | Parts out of 16 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Widow | Sharer | 1/8, because the deceased left a child | 2 |
| Only daughter | Sharer | 1/2, as a single daughter with no son | 8 |
| Nephew 1 | Residuary | Half of the remaining 3/8 | 3 |
| Nephew 2 | Residuary | Half of the remaining 3/8 | 3 |
| Each niece | Distant Kindred | Nothing in this estate | 0 |
Look at the result. The two women closest to the deceased take ten parts out of sixteen. The nieces take nothing, not because they are women, but because their class never reached the front of the queue.

The Appeal: A Division Bench Said the Same Thing
The story did not end in May 2024. One of the nieces challenged the order through High Court Appeal No. 219 of 2024. A Division Bench of Chief Justice Muhammad Shafi Siddiqui and Justice Jawad Akbar Sarwana heard it and dismissed it on 30 January 2025.
The bench looked at the table of Residuaries in paragraph 65 of Mulla. It lists the “full brother’s son” but not the full brother’s daughter. In the bench’s words, “The absence of mention of ‘daughter’ in the category of Residuaries carries weight.” (Para 7)
The bench then pointed to paragraph 68, which lists a brother’s daughter in the third class of Distant Kindred. It held that she, and any other real sister of the nephews, could not inherit from this estate. You can read the appeal judgment on the Sindh High Court website.
Does Section 4 of the Family Laws Ordinance Help Nieces?
The nieces’ idea that their father’s share should pass to his children sounds like a rule many people have heard of. That rule exists, but it is narrow. Section 4 of the Muslim Family Laws Ordinance, 1961 gives the children of a predeceased son or daughter the share their parent would have taken.
It speaks of a son or daughter of the deceased, not a brother. In September 2026, a two-member bench of the Federal Constitutional Court of Pakistan upheld a Lahore High Court decision that Section 4 does not reach the children of a predeceased brother. Because the brother died first, no inheritance ever opened in his favour, so nothing could pass to his children. More rulings of that court are in our Federal Constitutional Court judgments section.
When Can a Niece Inherit Under Hanafi Law?
This judgment is not a permanent ban on nieces. Under the Hanafi order described above, a niece who is Distant Kindred can inherit when the earlier classes are empty. For example, if a man dies leaving no Sharer and no Residuary at all, his brother’s daughters may inherit as Distant Kindred.
Mulla’s commentary also explains that a husband or wife does not shut out Distant Kindred. If the only Sharer is a widow, she takes her share and the balance can go to the Distant Kindred. Shares among several Distant Kindred follow detailed rules, so get a proper calculation.
That is why nieces inheritance rights Pakistan Hanafi law can never be answered by gender alone. The answer can also change if the brother was a half-brother, if other relatives are alive, or if the family follows Fiqh-e-Jafaria, where the structure of inheritance is different.

What the Court Did and Did Not Decide
The court did decide that:
- the widow and the minor daughter were Sharers;
- the two nephews were Residuaries, and the residue would be divided equally between them;
- the two nieces were Distant Kindred and took nothing while Sharers and Residuaries were present;
- the objections were misconceived, and the succession application was allowed as per rules.
The court did not decide that:
- women generally inherit less, or that nieces can never inherit;
- the exact fractions of each heir, which the reported order does not write out;
- any separate dispute over title to a particular property, since this was a succession application, not a full civil suit;
- the case of a Shia family, because the parties admitted they were Hanafi.
What This Means for Ordinary Families
For families, the lesson is simple: classify first, calculate later. A family tree drawn in a hurry, or a two-to-one rule applied to everyone, can give a share to the wrong person or deny it to the right one.
For a niece, the case is a reality check, not an insult. If any Sharer or Residuary is alive, her claim under Hanafi law is weak, and a long fight may only delay the certificate for everyone, including a minor child.
For widows and daughters, the case shows how strongly the law protects them. The minor daughter here was never at risk. If you are a daughter being pushed out of your father’s estate, read our guide on a daughter’s share in her father’s property.
Evidence and Next Steps for Families
Whether you are claiming a share or resisting one, collect these papers before anything is filed:
- the death certificate, and the dates of death of any relative who died earlier;
- the NADRA Family Registration Certificate and CNIC copies of all heirs;
- a full family tree that shows real, half and step relations;
- a list of bank accounts, securities, land and houses, with ownership documents;
- details of debts, funeral costs and any written will;
- any fatwa obtained; it helps, but the court decides on the law.
Where all heirs agree, NADRA’s succession route can be quicker. In Sindh, this route rests on the Sindh Letters of Administration and Succession Certificates Act, 2021. Where the heirs dispute who is an heir, as here, expect a court to decide it.
Avoid three common mistakes:
- signing a “no objection” affidavit without knowing what share you may be giving up;
- treating the Family Registration Certificate as a share calculator; it only lists family members;
- waiting too long after an order; appeal time limits are short, so speak to a lawyer at once.
For land and houses, our property inheritance guide explains the steps after the heirs are settled.
Nieces Inheritance Rights Pakistan Hanafi Law: 8 FAQs
1. Did the nieces get any share in 2026 CLC 120?
No. The court classed them as Distant Kindred. Because the widow and daughter (Sharers) and the two nephews (Residuaries) were alive, the nieces were not entitled to anything from this estate. Their objections were rejected as misconceived, and the succession application was allowed as per rules.
2. Was the decision changed on appeal?
No. One niece filed High Court Appeal No. 219 of 2024. A Division Bench of the Sindh High Court dismissed it on 30 January 2025. Relying on Mulla’s paragraphs 65 and 68, the bench held that a full brother’s daughter is Distant Kindred, not a Residuary, so the single judge’s order needed no interference.
3. Why does a brother’s son inherit but his sister does not?
A brother’s son is a male agnate, connected to the deceased through a male link. Hanafi law lists him among the Residuaries, who take what is left after the Sharers. A brother’s daughter is not on that list. She is Distant Kindred, and Distant Kindred wait until no Sharer or Residuary remains.
4. Can a niece ever inherit from her uncle under Hanafi law?
Yes. Under nieces inheritance rights Pakistan Hanafi law, a niece can inherit as Distant Kindred when no Sharer or Residuary is alive. Mulla also explains that a surviving husband or wife does not shut out Distant Kindred. Every family tree is different, so the share must be worked out on the full facts.
5. Does a sister always get half of her brother’s share?
No. The two-to-one rule applies where the woman and man stand in the same class and the law joins them, such as a son and daughter of the deceased, or his brother and sister. It does not apply to a brother’s son and a brother’s daughter, because they belong to different classes.
6. Can Section 4 MFLO give nieces their late father’s share?
No. Section 4 of the Muslim Family Laws Ordinance, 1961 (MFLO) covers only the children of a predeceased son or daughter of the deceased. In September 2026, the Federal Constitutional Court upheld a Lahore High Court decision that it does not extend to the children of a predeceased brother. A brother who died first inherits nothing, so nothing passes to his children.
7. Is a fatwa enough to decide who the legal heirs are?
A fatwa can guide a family and may be placed on the court record, as it was here. But the court decided the case by applying Hanafi law, Mulla’s textbook and Supreme Court judgments. If heirs disagree, the court’s order, not the fatwa, decides who is entitled.
8. What should a niece check before filing objections?
She should get the death certificate, the Family Registration Certificate, the dates of death of her father and other relatives, and a full family tree. Then she should check whether any Sharer or Residuary is alive. A lawyer can tell her quickly whether she is entitled under the facts, before costs pile up.
Conclusion: Family Tree First, Shares Later
Two sisters went to court because their brothers were named heirs and they were not. It felt unfair, and many families will understand that pain. But the court’s answer was about classes, not gender. The widow and daughter came first as Sharers, the nephews took the rest as Residuaries, and the nieces waited in a queue that never opened.
If your family faces a question about nieces inheritance rights Pakistan Hanafi law, start with a complete family tree, settle debts and legacies, and classify every heir before anyone talks about fractions. More guides are in our inheritance law section and our women’s inheritance rights section.
Disclaimer
This article is for legal awareness only and is not legal advice. It explains 2026 CLC 120 and the appeal that followed; it is not a share calculation for your family. Every case depends on its own facts, documents and evidence, including the sect, the full family tree and the order of deaths. For your specific matter, consult a qualified lawyer.