
Imagine keeping a gift deed for a house and a shop for fifteen years, only to hear the courts say the gift was never complete. That is exactly what happened to a wife whose case began in a civil court at Haripur and ended in the Supreme Court as 2026 SCMR 499. She had the paper. What she could not prove was a valid gift in Pakistan.
For a valid gift in Pakistan, Islamic law as our courts apply it says a gift (hiba) stands on three legs: a clear offer by the giver, acceptance by the receiver and real delivery of possession. Remove one leg and the gift falls, no matter how neat the gift deed (hiba nama) looks. Two courts found all three legs missing here, and the Supreme Court refused to disturb that finding.
Below, we explain what happened, why the gift failed, why a separate house given in lieu of dower survived, and what you should do to protect a genuine gift in your own family.
Table of Contents
Judgment at a Glance: 2026 SCMR 499
| Point | Detail |
|---|---|
| Case title | Mst. Edan Bibi v. Naseem Khan and others |
| Citation | 2026 SCMR 499 |
| Court | Supreme Court of Pakistan |
| Bench | Justice Naeem Akhter Afghan and Justice Muhammad Shafi Siddiqui |
| Case number | Civil Petition No. 1189 of 2025 |
| Date of decision | 22 April 2025 |
| Order challenged | Peshawar High Court, Abbottabad Bench, judgment of 27 February 2025 in Civil Revision No. 356-A of 2022 |
| Law involved | Specific Relief Act, 1877 (sections 8, 42 and 54); Muslim law of gift (hiba) |
| Property | One house transferred in lieu of dower; another house and a shop under a gift deed dated 11 May 2010 |
| Result | Petition dismissed and leave refused: the gift claim stays rejected, the dower house stays with the wife |
IRAC Breakdown: Why the Gift Claim Failed
| IRAC | Explanation |
|---|---|
| Issue | Could the Supreme Court overturn concurrent findings that the 2010 gift was incomplete, when the wife argued the evidence was wrongly appreciated? |
| Rule | A valid gift in Pakistan needs offer, acceptance and delivery of possession. The Supreme Court does not disturb concurrent findings unless a party shows misread or ignored evidence, or an illegality or irregularity. |
| Analysis | The appellate court examined every witness and document. The High Court did not change those findings. The wife could not point to any piece of evidence that was misread or ignored. |
| Conclusion | No ground to interfere. The petition was dismissed, leave was refused and the gift part of her claim stayed rejected. |
Background: A Wife, a Dower House and a Gift Deed
The wife filed a civil suit for declaration, injunction and possession. She claimed ownership of the suit properties on two separate grounds:
- Her husband had transferred a house to her in lieu of dower (haq mehr).
- He had also gifted her another house and a shop through a gift deed dated 11 May 2010.
She also challenged Inheritance Mutation No. 949, dated 28 July 2011, entered for the suit properties. An inheritance mutation records property passing to legal heirs. So the real fight was simple: did these properties belong to her alone, or were they part of an estate for the heirs? The respondents contested the suit.
How the Case Travelled Through Four Courts
This was not a quick case. It went up and down the court ladder twice before reaching the Supreme Court.
| Date | Court | What happened |
|---|---|---|
| First round | Civil Court, Haripur | Decreed the suit only for prayer (A); the remaining relief was declined |
| 4 March 2017 | First appellate court | Remanded the case |
| 1 October 2020 | Peshawar High Court, Abbottabad Bench | Set aside both judgments and sent the case back to re-write the judgment |
| 15 September 2021 | Civil Court, Haripur | Decided afresh and decreed the whole suit as prayed |
| 28 September 2022 | Additional District Judge-III, Haripur (Civil Appeal No. 68/13 of 2021) | Partly allowed the appeal: dower house upheld, gift-deed relief set aside, Mutation No. 949 restored |
| 27 February 2025 | Peshawar High Court, Abbottabad Bench (Civil Revision No. 356-A of 2022) | Maintained the appellate judgment |
| 22 April 2025 | Supreme Court of Pakistan | Dismissed the petition and refused leave to appeal |
After the remand, some fresh evidence was recorded, and both sides also relied on the evidence recorded earlier (para 6).

What Each Side Argued Before the Supreme Court
Before the Supreme Court, the wife’s counsel accepted that the two courts immediately below had decided against her. Counsel’s argument was narrow: the appellate court and the High Court had wrongly appreciated the evidence.
No one appeared for the respondents; the order records them as “Nemo”. In the lower courts, they had contested the suit and won their appeal on the gift-deed part.
Where the Evidence Fell Short
The Supreme Court read the trial court’s judgment, the appellate court’s judgment and the High Court’s order. It noted that the first appellate court had discussed every witness and the documents each one exhibited (para 5).
In the second round, the appellate court examined the witness statements minutely and formed its own view, which prevailed over the trial court’s reading of the evidence. The High Court, sitting in revision, was not required to re-appraise the evidence, but it did not change those findings (para 8).
The central finding was this: the gift was incomplete for lack of offer, acceptance and delivery of possession (para 9). In plain words, the courts were not satisfied that the husband clearly offered the property as a gift, that the wife accepted it, and that possession actually passed to her.
The published order does not list each witness or explain which document failed on which point. What it makes clear is that a gift deed on file cannot replace the three proofs of a valid gift in Pakistan.
The Law Behind a Valid Gift in Pakistan

For Muslims, gifts are governed mainly by Islamic personal law as applied by the courts. Section 129 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882 says the Act’s chapter on gifts does not affect any rule of Muhammadan law. That is why three essentials, not the Act’s formal rules, decide most hiba disputes.
Declaration or Offer by the Donor (Ijab)
The donor, the person giving, must clearly and voluntarily declare an intention to give the property now, without payment. A promise to give later, or a vague remark, is not enough. Courts also look at the donor’s age, health and free will, especially where the donor is elderly, ill or a parda nasheen woman.
Acceptance by the Donee (Qabool)
The donee, the person receiving, must accept the gift by words or conduct during the donor’s lifetime. Where the donee is a minor, a guardian can accept on the child’s behalf.
Delivery of Possession (Qabza)
This is where most gift claims collapse. The donor must hand over possession, actual or constructive, and give up control. For a house or shop, that can mean handing over the keys, letting the donee collect rent, or moving tenancy, utility and tax records into the donee’s name. Courts want to know when, where and before whom possession was delivered.
Does a Gift Deed Need Registration?
Section 17(1)(a) of the Registration Act, 1908 lists instruments of gift of immovable property among documents that must be registered. Section 49 adds that an unregistered compulsory document cannot pass title to immovable property. Courts still recognise an oral gift in Pakistan if its three essentials are proved; a later writing then only records a past gift.
Either way, registration alone does not make a valid gift in Pakistan. The Supreme Court has held that a donee claiming under a gift that excludes an heir must establish the original transaction, even where a registered deed exists, as quoted by the Sindh High Court in R.A. No. 100 of 2015 (citing Fareed v. Muhammad Tufail, 2018 SCMR 139). For drafting and procedure, read our guide on the gift deed in Pakistan.
Is Mutation (Intiqal) Proof of a Gift?

No. A mutation is an entry in the revenue record. It shows that a transaction was reported, not that it legally took place. When a gift mutation is challenged, the beneficiary must prove both the mutation and the gift itself through reliable evidence, as the Supreme Court held in Muhammad Sarwar v. Mumtaz Bibi (2020 SCMR 276), quoted in the same Sindh High Court judgment. Our guide on inheritance mutation in Pakistan explains how these entries work.
The burden sits with the person relying on the gift. Under Article 117 of the Qanun-e-Shahadat Order, 1984, whoever asks a court to act on a fact must prove that fact.
Why the Supreme Court Refused to Interfere
The Supreme Court does not hold a fresh trial. When two courts below agree on the facts, it steps in only if a party shows a clear legal error, or points to specific evidence that was misread or ignored and would have changed the result.
The wife could not do that. Because she failed to point out any illegality, irregularity or misread evidence, the Court held that “this Court cannot interfere in the concurrent findings of the two courts below” (para 9).
Notice one painful detail. The trial court had ruled fully in her favour in 2021. Yet the appellate court’s findings, maintained by the High Court, became the concurrent findings that counted. A trial-court win is not the finish line.
Final Decision: Dower House Stayed, Gift Claim Failed
On 22 April 2025, the Supreme Court dismissed the petition and refused leave to appeal. The appellate decree of 28 September 2022 therefore stands:
- The house transferred in lieu of dower remains decreed in the wife’s favour.
- The relief based on the gift deed of 11 May 2010, covering a house and a shop, stays set aside.
- Inheritance Mutation No. 949 stays restored.
What the Court Did and Did Not Decide
The Supreme Court did:
- Refuse to disturb concurrent findings that the gift lacked offer, acceptance and delivery of possession.
- Make clear that a general complaint of “wrong appreciation of evidence” is not enough at the leave stage.
The Supreme Court did not:
- Lay down a new rule of gift law. It applied settled principles.
- Find the gift deed forged or fake. The courts found the gift incomplete, which is a different thing.
- Decide each heir’s share under the restored inheritance mutation.
- Disturb the dower-house transfer upheld by the appellate court.
- Grant leave or hear a full appeal on the merits.
Dower Transfer vs Gift: Why One Survived

The same wife kept one property and lost two others in the same case. The reason is that a transfer in lieu of dower and a gift are different transactions.
Dower (haq mehr) is the wife’s legal right against her husband. When he transfers property to settle it, the transfer stands against that right. A gift is made with nothing in return, so a valid gift in Pakistan needs proof of offer, acceptance and possession. The published order does not detail why the dower transfer was proved, but the outcome shows each transfer was tested on its own footing.
| Point | Transfer in lieu of dower | Gift (hiba) |
|---|---|---|
| Basis | Settles the wife’s dower right | Free transfer, nothing in return |
| What must be shown | The dower right and the transfer made against it | Offer, acceptance and delivery of possession |
| Result in 2026 SCMR 499 | Upheld | Not proved |
The lesson: if property is meant to settle dower, record that clearly. Do not dress it up as a gift, and do not assume a gift label will be easier to defend.
What This Judgment Means for Ordinary Families
- Gifts between husband and wife face the same three tests as any valid gift in Pakistan. Love, marriage or living together does not prove a gift.
- A gift deed is evidence, not magic. Without proof of possession, it can fail.
- Build your record at trial. Witnesses, keys, rent receipts and utility bills must reach the trial court; the Supreme Court will not search the file for you.
- If you appeal, be specific. Name the witness, the exhibit and the exact finding the lower court got wrong.
- Heirs are protected. Where a gift cuts heirs out, the person relying on it must prove it fully.
Evidence to Keep and Your Next Steps

These steps help a genuine, valid gift in Pakistan survive a challenge years later, when memories fade and witnesses move away.
If You Are Making a Gift
- Confirm the property is in your name in the revenue or registration record.
- Declare the gift clearly before reliable witnesses who will still be available years later.
- Hand over possession: keys, tenants, rent and bills. Stop acting as the owner.
- Get the deed stamped and registered where the law requires, and apply promptly for the mutation (intiqal).
- Keep copies of the deed, registration record, mutation order, and tax and utility records.
If You Hold a Gift Deed
- Gather proof of possession now, while witnesses are alive: rent receipts, tenancy papers, utility bills and property tax records in your name.
- Identify the attesting witnesses and the deed writer, and keep track of them.
- If a suit is filed, plead the date, place and witnesses of the offer, acceptance and possession in detail.
If You Are an Heir Challenging a Gift
- Obtain certified copies of the deed, the mutation and the revenue record.
- File in the civil court with jurisdiction over the property. Common reliefs are possession (section 8), cancellation of the instrument (section 39), declaration (section 42) and injunction (section 54) under the Specific Relief Act, 1877. See our guides on a civil suit for declaration and cancellation of a gift deed.
- Do not delay. Time limits under the Limitation Act, 1908 can apply, often counted from when you learned of the document.
Common Mistakes That Sink a Gift
- Relying only on the deed or only on the mutation.
- Producing witnesses who were not present when the gift was made.
- The donor keeps the keys, rent or tenants after the “gift”.
- A vague description of the property.
- Treating a trial-court decree as the final word.
- Appealing on general grounds without naming the misread evidence.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the three requirements of a valid gift in Pakistan?
A valid gift in Pakistan needs three things: a clear, voluntary offer by the donor, acceptance by the donee, and delivery of possession, actual or constructive. Courts apply these Islamic law essentials to Muslim gifts. If any one is not proved, the gift is incomplete, as the appellate court and the Peshawar High Court found in 2026 SCMR 499.
Why did the gift fail in 2026 SCMR 499?
The appellate court and the High Court found the 2010 gift incomplete because offer, acceptance and delivery of possession were not proved. Before the Supreme Court, the wife could not identify any evidence that was misread or ignored. So the Court refused to disturb those concurrent findings and dismissed her petition on 22 April 2025.
Does this judgment mean a husband cannot gift property to his wife?
No. A husband can gift property to his wife. The judgment only shows that such a gift must be proved like any other: a clear offer, her acceptance and real delivery of possession. In the same case, a house transferred to her in lieu of dower was upheld because it was a different kind of transaction.
Is a registered gift deed enough to prove ownership?
Not always. Registration shows that a deed was executed and recorded, but courts still ask whether the gift itself was complete. The Supreme Court has held that a donee claiming under a gift that excludes an heir must prove the original transaction even when a registered deed exists. Keep proof of possession alongside the deed.
Can an oral gift be valid in Pakistan?
Yes. Under Muslim law, a gift can be made orally, without a written deed. But an oral gift is harder to prove. The person relying on it must give the date, place and witnesses of the offer, acceptance and delivery of possession, and back them with reliable evidence, especially when legal heirs are left out.
Is a gift mutation (intiqal) proof of ownership?
No. A mutation is a revenue entry, not a title document. When it is challenged, the beneficiary must prove both the mutation and the underlying gift through reliable evidence. A mutation keeps the record updated, but it cannot replace proof of offer, acceptance and possession.
Who has to prove a disputed gift?
The person relying on the gift. Under Article 117 of the Qanun-e-Shahadat Order, 1984, whoever asserts a fact must prove it. Courts look even more closely where a gift cuts out legal heirs, such as daughters or sisters, or where the donor was old, ill or dependent on the donee.
How can heirs challenge a fake gift deed or gift mutation?
Heirs can file a civil suit seeking declaration, cancellation of the deed, possession and injunction under the Specific Relief Act, 1877, in the civil court with jurisdiction over the property. Collect certified copies of the deed and revenue record first, and act quickly, because limitation periods can apply.
Conclusion
A valid gift in Pakistan is not created by paper alone. In 2026 SCMR 499, a wife held a gift deed for a house and a shop, yet the courts found no proof of offer, acceptance or delivery of possession. The Supreme Court would not reopen those findings. Her dower house survived only because it stood on a different legal footing.
If you are giving or receiving property, make the gift real: hand over possession, keep witnesses and records, and register where required. If you are an heir facing a doubtful gift, act early and demand proof. For more cases like this, browse our gift and hiba disputes section.
Disclaimer
This article is for legal awareness only and is not legal advice. Every case depends on its own facts, documents and evidence. For your specific matter, consult a qualified lawyer.