
Your husband has married again. Nobody asked you, and no notice came from the Union Council. Now you are scared about your haq mehr (dower), your child’s maintenance, and whether you are still his wife. This is exactly where second marriage law in Pakistan steps in. Under Section 6 of the Muslim Family Laws Ordinance, 1961, a married man needs the prior written permission of the Arbitration Council before he takes another wife.
In PLD 2025 Supreme Court 262, the Supreme Court showed what happens when a husband ignores that rule. He married again while appeals were pending and admitted he never applied for permission. The Court dissolved the first marriage on the wife’s statutory ground, refused to call it khula, and kept her dower and dowry decrees alive. Below, we explain the judgment, what second marriage law in Pakistan requires, the penalties and your next lawful steps.
Table of Contents
Judgment at a Glance: PLD 2025 SC 262
| Point | Detail |
|---|---|
| Court | Supreme Court of Pakistan |
| Bench | Syed Mansoor Ali Shah, Jamal Khan Mandokhail and Athar Minallah, JJ. (order by Athar Minallah, J.) |
| Case | Dr. F.M. and another v. K.S.D. and others, Civil Petitions Nos. 308-P and 1388 of 2019 |
| Citation | PLD 2025 Supreme Court 262 |
| Arising from | Peshawar High Court, Writ Petition No. 1341-P of 2016 |
| Heard and decided | Heard on 3 May 2024; decided on 23 October 2024 |
| Law involved | Sections 6 and 10, MFLO 1961; Section 2(iia), Dissolution of Muslim Marriages Act 1939 |
| Result | Marriage dissolved under Section 2(iia); khula and cruelty findings set aside; dower, dowry, maintenance and visitation decrees upheld |
We use initials because this family case involves a minor. The headnote dates the High Court judgment 3 April 2019; paragraph 1 of the order says 4 March 2019.
IRAC Breakdown: Why the Wife Won Under Section 2(iia)
| IRAC | Summary |
|---|---|
| Issue | Can a wife get her marriage dissolved because her husband took another wife without Arbitration Council permission? Could the lower courts order khula she never sought, or cruelty she never proved? |
| Rule | Section 6 MFLO requires the Council’s previous written permission. Section 2(iia) DMMA lets a wife seek dissolution if her husband takes an additional wife in breach of the MFLO. Khula needs the wife’s express or implied demand. |
| Analysis | The husband admitted he never applied. The 1981 repeal of Section 13 MFLO did not erase clause (iia). Khula was imposed without her demand, and the cruelty finding had no evidence or reasons. |
| Conclusion | Marriage dissolved under Section 2(iia). Khula, cruelty and restitution decrees set aside. Dower, dowry, maintenance and visitation decrees upheld. |
Second Marriage Law in Pakistan: The Short Answer
- A married Muslim man may contract another marriage (doosri shadi) only with the previous written permission of the Arbitration Council.
- The first wife’s consent is mentioned in the application, but it does not replace the Council’s permission.
- Without permission, the husband must pay the entire dower at once and can face simple imprisonment of up to one year, a fine, or both on a complaint.
- The existing wife can ask the Family Court to dissolve her marriage under Section 2(iia) of the DMMA 1939.
- Section 6 does not make the second nikah automatically void.
Background: A Marriage, a Son and a Long Court Fight
The couple married on 10 September 2007, and their son was born on 18 December 2008. They separated in 2012. On 28 July 2012, the wife sued for the dower recorded in the Nikahnama and her dowry articles (jahez), claiming an oral divorce. The husband denied the divorce and sought restitution of conjugal rights, a decree directing the wife to return home. He admitted the agreed dower but said Rs. 500,000 and 50 tolas of gold were paid at the Nikah.
How the Case Moved Through Four Courts
Trial Court (29 May 2014): The wife could not prove the oral divorce. She got Rs. 500,000 and her share in the house, or its market price, as dower. Her claim for 50 tolas of dower gold failed because the gold was given to her and stayed with her. Dowry articles, including 51 tolas of gold, were partly decreed, with maintenance and a visitation schedule. The husband got restitution, subject to paying prompt dower.
Appellate Court (Additional District Judge-V, Peshawar, 29 February 2016): While the appeals were pending, the husband took a second wife, and the wife added this as a new ground. The court entertained the ground but never decided it. Instead, it dissolved the marriage by khula, denied her dower, and adjusted the 50 tolas of dower gold against the 51 tolas of dowry gold. She had never asked for khula.
Peshawar High Court (Article 199): The husband accepted the appellate decree; the wife challenged it. The High Court set aside the khula and restored her dower and dowry decree, but dissolved the marriage for cruelty.
Supreme Court: Both sides sought leave. The Court converted the petitions into appeals and allowed them as explained below.

What Each Side Argued Before the Supreme Court
The husband’s counsel argued that:
- the courts could not decide dissolution because the wife had not prayed for it in her plaint;
- clause (iia) of Section 2 DMMA stood repealed, relying on a Peshawar High Court judgment in Rashid Ali’s case;
- a court may grant khula even if the wife never sought it, relying on Muhammad Arif’s case, decided by a two-member bench;
- the case should be remanded to record evidence on the second-marriage ground.
The wife’s stance was that taking a second wife in breach of the MFLO is itself a ground for dissolution under Section 2 DMMA. She had never asked for khula.
The Evidence That Settled the Case
The decisive evidence was an admission. The husband’s reply before the appellate court did not deny the breach, and in the Supreme Court his counsel, after taking instructions, conceded that the second wife was taken without the Arbitration Council’s permission (paragraph 12). On dower, the Nikahnama (Ex. PW-1/1) did the work: columns 13 to 16 recorded Rs. 500,000 cash on demand, a blank prompt-or-deferred column, 50 tolas of gold, and the husband’s house share registered in the wife’s name.
Second Marriage Law in Pakistan: How Section 6 Permission Works
The core of second marriage law in Pakistan is one sentence in Section 6 of the MFLO: no man, during an existing marriage, shall contract another marriage except with the previous permission in writing of the Arbitration Council (salisi council). The Supreme Court summarised the process in paragraph 9:
- The husband applies to the Chairman, with the prescribed fee.
- The application gives the reasons for the proposed marriage and says whether the existing wife or wives consent.
- The husband and each existing wife nominate a representative. Together with the Chairman, they form the Arbitration Council.
- The Council may grant permission only if satisfied that the marriage is necessary and just, and it may add conditions.
- The Council records its reasons.
- Any party may seek revision before the Collector concerned.
“Chairman” means the Union Council Chairman or an officer the government authorises. Rule 14 of the West Pakistan Rules under the MFLO gives examples the Council may weigh, such as the existing wife’s sterility, physical infirmity, unfitness for conjugal relations, wilful avoidance of a restitution decree, or insanity.

First Wife’s Consent vs Arbitration Council Permission
Many families believe a signed consent paper from the first wife makes a second nikah legal. Under second marriage law in Pakistan, that is not enough. Consent is one fact the husband must disclose; permission is the Council’s written decision.
| Question | First wife’s consent | Arbitration Council permission |
|---|---|---|
| What is it? | Her agreement to the proposed marriage | A written decision under Section 6 |
| Enough on its own? | No | Yes, if given before the nikah |
| Who decides? | The wife | Chairman and both sides’ representatives |
| If it is missing? | The Council can still hear the application | The husband is in breach of Section 6 |

What Happens If a Husband Remarries Without Permission?
Section 6(5) of the MFLO attaches two consequences, and the DMMA adds a third. Each runs separately, so a wife can use one, two or all three.
1. The Entire Dower Becomes Payable at Once
The husband must immediately pay the whole dower due to the existing wife or wives, prompt and deferred. If unpaid, the MFLO makes it recoverable as arrears of land revenue, and the wife can also claim it in the Family Court.
2. Jail or Fine After a Complaint
On conviction upon a complaint, the husband can face simple imprisonment of up to one year, a fine, or both (in Punjab, both). The case starts only on a complaint, and the fine depends on your province, as the table below shows.
3. The First Wife Can Seek Dissolution
Section 2(iia) of the DMMA 1939 lets a wife obtain dissolution of marriage (tanseekh-e-nikah) if her husband takes an additional wife in breach of the MFLO. The Supreme Court said all she must show is that breach of Section 6 (paragraph 9). Section 5 of the DMMA keeps her dower rights intact.

Punishment in Punjab vs Islamabad and Other Provinces
Penalties under second marriage law in Pakistan are not the same everywhere, so never apply the Punjab figure in another province.
| Area | Penalty under Section 6(5)(b) | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Punjab | Simple imprisonment up to one year and a fine of Rs. 500,000 | Punjab Muslim Family Laws (Amendment) Act 2015 |
| Islamabad Capital Territory | Simple imprisonment up to one year, or a fine up to Rs. 5,000, or both | Federal MFLO text |
| Sindh, KP, Balochistan | Original Rs. 5,000 wording unless the province has amended it | Provincial code |
The Supreme Court’s Reasoning, Point by Point
Section 2(iia) Still Stands After the 1981 Repeal
Clause (iia) entered the DMMA through Section 13 of the MFLO. In 1981, the Federal Laws (Revision and Declaration) Ordinance omitted Section 13, and the husband argued clause (iia) went with it. The Court disagreed: Section 7 of that Ordinance and Section 6-A of the General Clauses Act 1897 save amendments already made. It held the Peshawar High Court’s contrary view per incuriam, meaning decided without considering the relevant law. Clause (iia), the Court said, “continues to be one of the valid, effective and subsisting grounds for dissolution of marriage” (paragraph 9).
A Court Cannot Impose Khula on a Wife
Khula is the wife’s right. A court can grant it against the husband’s will, but cannot order it on its own when the wife has not sought it, expressly or impliedly. The Court followed the five-member bench in Mst. Khurshid Bibi v. Baboo Muhammad Amin (PLD 1967 SC 97) and declined to follow Muhammad Arif’s case (paragraph 10). This matters because khula usually costs the wife her dower.
Cruelty Must Be Proved With Evidence
Cruelty can be mental or physical, as held in Mst. Tayyeba Ambareen v. Shafqat Ali Kiyani (2023 SCMR 246). But the trial court had decided the cruelty issue against the wife, and no further evidence was recorded. In Article 199 jurisdiction, the High Court could not decide such factual questions, and it gave no reasons (paragraph 11).
The Nikahnama Decided the Dower
The Nikahnama is the deed of the marriage contract, carries a strong presumption of truth, and is read by the parties’ intention, not just column headings. Unspecified dower is presumed prompt under Section 10 MFLO (paragraph 6). Here the gold and house share were prompt, and the cash was payable on demand.
Why the Case Was Not Sent Back
The husband wanted a remand for evidence. The Court called it futile because the breach stood admitted: he never applied, and the Council never granted permission (paragraph 12).
Final Decision: What the Supreme Court Ordered
- The marriage stands dissolved on the ground in Section 2(iia) of the DMMA 1939.
- The khula decree and the cruelty dissolution are illegal and set aside.
- The restitution of conjugal rights decree is set aside.
- The trial court’s decrees for dower, dowry articles, maintenance and visitation are upheld (paragraphs 12 and 13).
What the Court Did Not Decide
- It did not declare the husband’s second marriage void.
- It did not convict the husband under Section 6(5)(b); no criminal complaint was before it.
- It did not judge whether the second marriage was “necessary and just”, because no application was ever made.
- It did not reopen the oral divorce claim, which the wife had failed to prove.
After the Judgment: CII Objection, New Cases and Bills
None of these has changed the core of second marriage law in Pakistan, but you should know them:
- CII opinion (March 2025): The Council of Islamic Ideology called the ruling un-Islamic. Under Article 230 of the Constitution, the CII only advises and recommends; its opinion does not set aside a Supreme Court judgment.
- Later Supreme Court cases: Later benches again treated an unauthorised second marriage as a dissolution ground and barred forced khula, including Dr. Seema Hanif Khan’s case (2025) and Naila Javed’s case (January 2026). Follow such rulings in our Supreme Court judgments section.
- Islamabad Domestic Violence Act 2026: The Domestic Violence (Prevention and Protection) Act, 2026 treats threats of divorce or a second marriage on a baseless accusation of insanity or infertility as psychological abuse, punishable with six months to three years where the PPC does not apply. It covers Islamabad only.
- Senate bill: A private member’s Muslim Family Laws (Amendment) Bill, 2026 is pending; media reports say it proposes a higher fine. A bill is not law until passed and notified.
What This Means for Wives and Husbands
For wives, second marriage law in Pakistan now offers a clear, standalone ground. You do not have to prove cruelty or accept khula. If your case is already pending when he remarries, you can raise the new ground in the same proceedings, as this wife did on appeal.
For husbands, apply to the Arbitration Council before the nikah. A consent paper or family agreement is not permission, and skipping the process makes the full dower payable at once.
Evidence the First Wife Should Preserve
- A certified copy of your Nikahnama, especially dower columns 13 to 16.
- A certified copy of the second Nikahnama, including the columns on an existing wife and Council permission (21 and 22 in the standard form).
- A Union Council letter on whether any Section 6 application was made.
- Invitations, photos, posts or witnesses showing the second marriage and its date.
- The husband’s written statement, replies or messages admitting it.
- Dower, dowry and maintenance records, and your child’s school records.

Your Next Lawful Steps (and Common Mistakes)
- Get certified copies of both Nikahnamas from the Union Councils where they were registered.
- Ask the Union Council whether any Section 6 application was filed or approved.
- File, or amend, a Family Court suit for dissolution under Section 2(iia), with dower, dowry and maintenance claims.
- For criminal action, file a complaint through the proper route; the forum differs by province, so confirm it with your lawyer.
- Seek interim maintenance and, if needed, a custody or visitation order. Our guide on divorce procedure in Pakistan explains related steps.
Common mistakes to avoid:
- Accepting khula when you have a statutory ground; it can cost your dower. Compare the grounds for khula first.
- Treating a stamp-paper “consent” or a verbal promise as Council permission.
- Pleading cruelty without evidence.
- Delaying dower and dowry claims, since limitation rules can apply.
FAQs: Second Marriage Law in Pakistan
Is the first wife’s consent required for a second marriage?
Not as a separate legal test. The husband must state whether his existing wife consents, but the Arbitration Council decides. Her consent alone does not make the second marriage lawful, and her refusal does not stop the Council from granting permission if it finds the marriage necessary and just.
What is the punishment for second marriage without permission?
The husband must pay the entire dower at once. On conviction upon a complaint, the federal text allows simple imprisonment of up to one year, a fine of up to Rs. 5,000, or both. In Punjab, the 2015 amendment provides up to one year’s simple imprisonment and a fine of Rs. 500,000.
Is a second nikah without Arbitration Council permission void?
No. Section 6 punishes the husband but does not declare the second marriage void, and PLD 2025 SC 262 did not declare it void either. The second wife keeps her own rights, such as dower and maintenance. The consequences fall on the husband.
How does a husband apply for permission for a second marriage?
He submits a written application with the prescribed fee to the Chairman, giving reasons and stating whether his existing wife or wives consent. Each side nominates a representative to the Arbitration Council, which decides with recorded reasons. Either side can seek revision before the Collector.
Can the first wife get divorce if he remarries without permission?
Yes. Section 2(iia) of the DMMA 1939 lets her seek dissolution of marriage because of the unauthorised second marriage. In PLD 2025 SC 262, the Supreme Court dissolved the marriage on exactly this ground and held that a court cannot turn her case into khula she never asked for.
Will the first wife lose her haq mehr on this ground?
No. In PLD 2025 SC 262, the dower and dowry decrees were upheld once the marriage was dissolved under Section 2(iia) instead of khula. Section 5 of the DMMA protects her dower on such a dissolution, and Section 6(5)(a) of the MFLO makes the entire dower payable immediately.
Is there a new second marriage law in Pakistan in 2026?
No. Second marriage law in Pakistan still rests on Section 6 of the MFLO, which no new federal law has changed. A Muslim Family Laws (Amendment) Bill, 2026 is pending in the Senate. In Islamabad, the Domestic Violence Act 2026 now treats baseless threats of a second marriage as abuse.
What is the punishment if a wife marries again without divorce?
A Muslim woman cannot validly marry while her first marriage subsists, so that second marriage is void. Section 494 of the Pakistan Penal Code punishes such a marriage with up to seven years’ imprisonment and fine. Under Section 495, concealing the earlier marriage raises the maximum to ten years.
Conclusion: The First Wife Is Not Powerless
Second marriage law in Pakistan does not ban a second marriage, but it does not let a husband skip the Arbitration Council either. PLD 2025 SC 262 makes three things clear: an unauthorised second marriage gives the first wife a live ground for dissolution, a court cannot push her into khula, and her dower and dowry decrees survive. If you face this situation, collect your documents early and take advice before choosing your ground. Read more on women’s rights in Pakistan.
Disclaimer
This article is for legal awareness only and is not legal advice. Every case depends on its own facts, documents and evidence. Penalties and procedure can differ by province. For your specific matter, consult a qualified lawyer.