
A woman goes to court to leave a marriage she says has become cruel. Her husband has already married again without her permission. She asks the Family Court to dissolve the marriage on legal grounds. Instead, the court gives her khula, a remedy she never asked for, and orders her to hand back her gold and a residential plot.
This happened to a woman doctor in Peshawar. It took her more than eight years and a trip to the Supreme Court to set it right. Her story shows that the khula process in Pakistan really begins before the first hearing, with one quiet choice: khula or dissolution.
This guide walks you through every step, from the plaint to the NADRA record, and explains what the Supreme Court said in PLD 2026 SC 91.
Table of Contents
Judgment at a Glance: PLD 2026 SC 91
| Point | Detail |
|---|---|
| Case | Dr. S. H. K. v. W. K. and others |
| Citation | PLD 2026 Supreme Court 91 |
| Court and bench | Supreme Court of Pakistan; Justice Ayesha A. Malik (author) and Justice Naeem Akhter Afghan |
| Case number | C.P.L.A. No. 3268 of 2024 |
| Decided on | 19 September 2025 |
| Order challenged | Peshawar High Court, W.P. No. 5015-P of 2020, dated 27 May 2024 |
| Laws involved | Dissolution of Muslim Marriages Act 1939, sections 2(ii), 2(ii-a) and 2(viii); Muslim Family Laws Ordinance 1961, section 6; Family Courts Act 1964 |
| Result in one line | Khula set aside; marriage dissolved because of the husband’s unlawful second marriage; wife keeps her full dower and gets maintenance |
IRAC: Why the Court Rejected Forced Khula
| IRAC | Summary |
|---|---|
| Issue | Can a Family Court grant khula on its own when the wife sued for dissolution under the DMMA? And what standard of proof applies to cruelty, unpaid maintenance and a second marriage? |
| Rule | Khula needs the wife’s free and informed consent (Ibrahim Khan v. Mst. Saima Khan, PLD 2024 SC 645). DMMA grounds are proved on the balance of probabilities. A second marriage without permission under section 6 of the MFLO is a ground under section 2(ii-a) of the DMMA. |
| Analysis | The wife never asked for khula. The lower courts demanded FIRs and medical reports, brushed aside her witnesses, and ignored the husband’s admitted second marriage and his conviction for it. |
| Conclusion | Khula and the dower order set aside; marriage dissolved under section 2(ii-a); wife keeps her full dower and gets maintenance for the marriage period. |
Khula or Dissolution: Make This Choice Before You File
Pakistani law gives a wife two different court routes out of a marriage. Many women do not know the difference, and that is exactly where trouble starts.
Khula is the wife’s right to end a marriage she cannot continue. She does not have to prove that the husband did anything wrong, and his refusal cannot block it. In return, the court can ask her to give back some of what she received, usually her haq mehr (dower). That return is called zar-e-khula.
Dissolution under the DMMA works differently. The Dissolution of Muslim Marriages Act, 1939 lists grounds such as cruelty, no maintenance for two years, and the husband taking another wife in breach of the MFLO. If she proves a ground, the marriage ends and she keeps her dower. Our guide to grounds for khula in Pakistan explains the common grounds one by one.
| Question | Khula | Dissolution under the DMMA |
|---|---|---|
| What is it based on? | The wife’s decision that she cannot live with him | A ground listed in section 2 of the DMMA |
| What must she prove? | That she cannot continue the marriage | The ground, on the balance of probabilities |
| Haq mehr | The court may order part of it returned | She keeps it, and unpaid dower stays due |
| Husband’s consent | Not needed | Not needed |
| Usual speed | Often decided at the pre-trial stage | Usually needs full evidence, so slower |
PLD 2026 SC 91 makes this choice matter in law, not just on paper. The court said that “filing of a suit for dissolution does not in itself amount to seeking khula” (para 13). A judge must record the wife’s consent and make sure she understands that khula can cost her the dower. Anger, silence, or living at her parents’ home is not consent.
So be clear from day one, because the khula process in Pakistan only protects you when the record shows what you chose. If you want dissolution only, say so in your plaint and in your statement. If you would accept khula as a last option, say that too, knowing what it may cost.

Khula Process in Pakistan: 9 Steps From Plaint to Certificate
Here is how the khula process in Pakistan usually moves through the Family Court. Details change from province to province and court to court, so treat this as a map, not a promise.
Step 1: Collect Your Nikahnama and Proof
Get a copy of your nikahnama (marriage contract) and read the dower and maintenance columns carefully. In the Supreme Court case, a column promised Rs 10,000 a month as maintenance, and that line later won her the money. Also collect CNIC copies, children’s details and any messages, photos, medical slips or police complaints.
Step 2: Choose the Right Family Court
Rule 6 of the West Pakistan Family Courts Rules, 1965 lets you sue where the cause of action arose or where the couple lives or last lived together. For dissolution and dower, its proviso adds the court where the wife ordinarily resides. So a wife now living with her parents in another city can usually file there.
Step 3: File the Suit (Plaint)
Your lawyer drafts the plaint (dawa) under the Family Courts Act, 1964. It sets out the facts, the grounds and exactly what you ask for: dissolution or khula, dower, maintenance and dowry articles (jahez). Read every line before you sign. In the Supreme Court case, the written plaint clearly asked for dissolution, and that record saved the wife years later.
Step 4: Summons to the Husband
The court sends summons to the husband. In Punjab, the 2015 amendment asks the court to fix his appearance within 15 days. If he stays away after proper service, the court can proceed without him (ex parte), so give his correct address.
Step 5: Written Statement and Pre-Trial Reconciliation
The husband files his written statement (jawab-e-dawa). The judge then holds pre-trial proceedings and tries to bring the couple together. You can tell the judge, calmly and plainly, that you cannot continue the marriage and why.
Step 6: Khula Decree or Full Trial
If reconciliation fails and the wife has asked for khula, the court can pass the decree straight away. Punjab’s section 10(5), as amended in 2015, says this expressly. If she has asked for dissolution on a DMMA ground, the court frames the points in dispute and records evidence from both sides.
Step 7: Dower, Dowry, Maintenance and Children
The court then decides the money claims joined with the suit, such as dower, dowry articles and maintenance. A khula decree does not end a father’s duty to support his children, and custody turns on the child’s welfare. See our guide on custody of minor in Pakistan.
Step 8: The Decree Goes to the Union Council
The court sends a certified copy of the decree to the Chairman of the Union Council. In Punjab, section 21-B requires this within three days. The Chairman then acts as if he had received a talaq notice under the MFLO. Our divorce procedure in Pakistan guide explains this Union Council stage in more detail.
Step 9: 90 Days, Certificate and NADRA Record
The decree takes effect once the 90-day Union Council period passes without reconciliation. You can then apply for the divorce (khula) certificate and get your NADRA record updated. Keep several certified copies of the decree for remarriage, passports and visas.

Documents You Need for a Khula Case
Every khula case runs on paper, and the khula process in Pakistan is no exception. Bring these to your first meeting with a lawyer; a missing paper will not end your case, but a complete file saves weeks.
- Nikahnama copy, ideally certified by the Union Council
- Your CNIC copy, plus your husband’s full name and current address
- Children’s B-forms or birth certificates, if any
- List of dowry articles, with receipts or photos
- Proof of dower: gold details, property papers, bank transfers
- Proof of cruelty or neglect: messages, voice notes, photos, medical slips, police complaints
- Proof of a second marriage, such as the second nikahnama
- A special power of attorney, if you live abroad

How Much Haq Mehr Goes Back in Khula?
This is the part of the khula procedure in Pakistan that surprises most women. The court can ask the wife to give back part of her dower, and how much depends on where you live and on your facts.
- Punjab: Under the Punjab Family Courts (Amendment) Act 2015, the court “may” direct the wife to surrender up to 50% of her deferred dower or up to 25% of her admitted prompt dower. These are upper limits, not fixed amounts.
- Outside Punjab: The wording added to section 10(4) of the Family Courts Act in 2002 speaks of restoring to the husband the haq mehr the wife received at the time of marriage. Check whether your province has changed it.
- An open legal question: In 2022, the Federal Shariat Court held Punjab’s dower-surrender rule against Islamic injunctions (PLD 2022 FSC 25). Under Article 203D of the Constitution, such a ruling does not take effect while an appeal is pending, and the Supreme Court still applied section 10(5) in January 2026. Our guide on khula law in Pakistan and dower return explains that case.
- Dissolution instead of khula: If the marriage ends on a DMMA ground, there is no zar-e-khula at all. And if the husband married again without permission, section 6(5) of the MFLO makes the entire dower payable to the first wife at once.

How Long Does the Khula Process in Pakistan Take?
The khula process in Pakistan has no fixed timetable. If the husband is served and reconciliation fails, a khula decree can come within a few hearings at the pre-trial stage. A contested dissolution suit takes longer, because witnesses must be examined. Either way, add the 90-day Union Council period after the decree.
The Supreme Court case shows how badly things can drag when the wrong remedy is granted. The wife sued in July 2017 and got relief only in September 2025, more than eight years later, as the timeline below shows.
The Case Behind This Guide
The facts below come from the Supreme Court’s judgment. The parties are referred to as the wife and the husband.
Facts and Timeline
| Date | What happened |
|---|---|
| 31 May 2015 | Nikah. Dower fixed as a plot, 30 tola gold and Rs 500,000, with Rs 10,000 a month maintenance in the nikahnama |
| From 27 July 2016 | Three jirgas; the wife returned home each time; separate accommodation was later agreed |
| December 2016 | The wife leaves the marital home; no contact from the husband afterwards |
| 29 April 2017 | The husband marries again without her consent or Arbitration Council permission |
| 4 July 2017 | The wife sues for dissolution on cruelty, unpaid maintenance and the second marriage |
| 28 June 2018 | She files a criminal complaint under section 6(5) of the MFLO |
| 22 July 2019 | Family Court grants khula and orders her to return the gold and plot |
| 12 October 2020 | Her appeal is dismissed |
| 26 January 2023 | Magistrate convicts the husband under section 6(5); the conviction is never challenged |
| 27 May 2024 | Peshawar High Court dismisses her writ petition |
| 19 September 2025 | Supreme Court allows her appeal |
What Each Side Argued
The wife’s counsel said she sought dissolution for cruelty, unpaid maintenance and a second marriage, but the courts ignored her prayer and evidence, gave her khula without consent and took her dower. The khula label, counsel added, also hurt her dignity.
The husband’s counsel said it was really a khula case, because she kept saying she did not want to live with him. He argued cruelty was unproved and that leaving home for her career made her disobedient.
The Evidence Before the Court
The wife produced four witnesses: herself, her mother, a cousin and an uncle. They spoke of slaps that bruised her lip, abuse by in-laws, male servants walking into her rooms and an incident where she was thrown before pet dogs. Later, the husband stayed out till 2 or 3 a.m., blocked her number and paid no maintenance. A July 2016 police report backed her account.
The husband relied on his own statement and three jirga members. None of them spoke about his good behaviour or her so-called desertion. He also admitted the second marriage, both in his written statement and in his evidence.
What the Supreme Court Held
- Forced khula is unlawful. Khula rests on the wife’s consent and autonomy. A court cannot impose it to replace a DMMA ground it failed to examine.
- Cruelty is wider than beating. It covers physical, mental, verbal and emotional abuse; the examples in section 2(viii) are only illustrations. The impact on the wife is what matters.
- No criminal-trial standard. Cruelty is “not to be judged by a standard so rigid that it replicates a criminal trial” (para 9). The test is the balance of probabilities.
- A second marriage alone is enough. The husband admitted it, never sought permission and was convicted. That satisfied section 2(ii-a). See our guide on second marriage law in Pakistan.
- Maintenance is a legal duty. A “disobedient” label does not cancel it, and wanting to study or work abroad is her autonomy, not misconduct.
- Words matter. Family Courts must drop labels like “disobedient wife” and “self-deserting”, which clash with Articles 14, 25 and 35 of the Constitution.
Final Order
The petition was converted into an appeal and allowed. All three lower decisions were set aside to the extent of khula, dower and maintenance. The marriage was dissolved because the husband’s second marriage broke the law. The wife keeps the gold, money and plot, and gets Rs 10,000 a month maintenance for the period the marriage lasted, calculated according to law.
What the Court Did Not Decide
- It did not weaken khula. It protected khula as the wife’s own choice.
- It did not re-try every fact. It corrected the standard of proof the lower courts used.
- It did not rule on Punjab’s dower-surrender formula, because this was a Khyber Pakhtunkhwa case.
- It did not fix the final maintenance total. That is to be calculated according to law.
- It did not decide custody or any other property dispute.

What This Ruling Means for Ordinary Families
This ruling changes how the khula process in Pakistan works in real courtrooms. A judge cannot turn your dissolution suit into khula unless you clearly agree after understanding the cost. Your sworn account and the surrounding facts count, even without an FIR. A second marriage without permission is enough, on its own, to end the marriage.
For husbands, it is a warning. Skipping the section 6 process can make the entire dower payable at once and can lead to a criminal conviction.
Evidence to Keep and Mistakes to Avoid
Beyond the documents above, start a simple diary today, even if you have not decided anything yet. Courts weigh the whole picture, so small records add up.
- Write down dates of incidents while you still remember them
- Note the names of people who saw injuries or heard threats
- Keep bank records showing whether maintenance was paid
- Record the dates and members of any jirga or family meeting
Common mistakes in the khula procedure in Pakistan that hurt women in court:
- Signing the plaint without reading what it actually asks for.
- Telling the court only that you “do not want to live with him”, without explaining why. In this case, the husband used such statements to argue it was really khula.
- Agreeing to khula in court under pressure without knowing the cost to your mehr.
- Leaving out the second marriage or the unpaid maintenance as grounds.
- Forgetting the Union Council step after the decree.
Keep an eye on deadlines too. The maintenance ground needs two years of neglect, the Union Council period is 90 days, and appeals have short time limits. If your husband married again without permission, ask your lawyer about a complaint under section 6(5) of the Muslim Family Laws Ordinance, 1961, as the wife did here. If a decree goes wrong, see a lawyer at once about the right challenge, whether an appeal, revision or writ.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the khula process in Pakistan in simple words?
The wife files a suit in the Family Court, the husband is summoned, and the judge tries to reconcile them. If that fails, the court passes a khula decree and decides any dower to be returned. The decree goes to the Union Council, and after 90 days the divorce takes effect.
Can a Family Court give me khula if I asked for dissolution?
No, not on its own. In PLD 2026 SC 91, the Supreme Court held that khula rests on the wife’s consent and cannot replace a DMMA ground. The judge must record your consent and make sure you understand it can cost you your dower.
Do I have to return my full haq mehr in khula?
Not always. In Punjab, the court may order you to surrender up to 25% of admitted prompt dower or up to 50% of deferred dower; these are upper limits. Outside Punjab, courts look at the dower received at marriage. Under a DMMA dissolution, you keep it.
Can my husband stop khula by refusing to sign?
No. Khula does not need the husband’s consent, because the Family Court decides it. He may slow things down by avoiding notices, but the court can proceed without him after proper service. Read our guide on khula without husband consent for the full picture.
Do I need an FIR or medical report to prove cruelty?
No. The Supreme Court said the law does not require injuries, police reports or medical reports for every slap or every instance of emotional abuse. The court must weigh your sworn statement, witnesses and surrounding facts on the balance of probabilities. Records still help.
Where do I file if I now live with my parents in another city?
Rule 6 of the West Pakistan Family Courts Rules, 1965 allows a wife to file a suit for dissolution of marriage or dower where she ordinarily resides. So you can usually file in the city where you live now, not only where your husband lives or where you married.
How long does khula take, and when can I remarry?
A khula decree can come within a few hearings if reconciliation fails; contested cases take longer. The Union Council stage then takes 90 days. Remarry only after the divorce is effective, your certificate is issued and your iddat is complete.
Can I file for khula while living abroad?
Usually, yes. Many overseas wives appoint a relative in Pakistan through a special power of attorney attested by a Pakistani embassy or consulate. The court may still want your own statement, so ask your lawyer how it will be recorded before you plan travel.
Conclusion
Khula is a strong right, but it is not the only door out of a harmful marriage, and it can cost you your mehr. Before you begin the khula process in Pakistan, decide which route fits your facts, say it clearly in your plaint and keep your evidence safe. PLD 2026 SC 91 settles one thing beyond doubt: no court can choose khula for you. Your words, your consent and your rights come first.
Disclaimer
This article is for legal awareness only and is not legal advice. Every case depends on its own facts, documents and evidence. For your specific matter, consult a qualified lawyer.