
Many families in Pakistan believe that a share in inheritance (wirasat) can never expire. That belief is only half true. The share comes from Islamic law, but the right to go to court for it can be lost if you stay silent for too long. This is the hard lesson of limitation in inheritance cases in Pakistan, and a Lahore High Court judgment reported as PLD 2026 Lahore 146 shows it very clearly.
In this case, a sister was left out of her brother’s inheritance mutation (intiqal) in 1952. She lived for about 36 more years and never challenged it. Her legal heirs filed a suit in 2009, about 21 years after her death. They lost. Here is what happened, why the court said no, and what you should do so your own claim does not meet the same end.
Table of Contents
Judgment at a Glance: PLD 2026 Lahore 146
| Point | Details |
|---|---|
| Court | Lahore High Court, Lahore |
| Bench | Justice Khalid Ishaq (single bench) |
| Case | Regular Second Appeal No. 17025 of 2020 |
| Parties | Jamshed Khan and 6 others v. Akbar Khan and 15 others |
| Citation | PLD 2026 Lahore 146 |
| Date of decision | 18 June 2025 |
| Appeal against | Judgment of the Additional District Judge, Tehsil Kamoke, District Gujranwala, dated 22 February 2020 |
| Law involved | Limitation Act, 1908 (section 18, Articles 95 and 120); West Pakistan Muslim Personal Law (Shariat) Application Act, 1948; settlement and rehabilitation laws; section 100 CPC |
| Result | Appeal allowed. The heirs’ suit was dismissed as barred by limitation and outside the civil court’s jurisdiction. |
You can find more rulings like this in our Lahore High Court judgments section.
IRAC Breakdown: Why the Heirs’ Claim Failed
| IRAC | Simple explanation |
|---|---|
| Issue | Could the heirs of a woman left out of a 1952 inheritance mutation challenge it in 2009, when she herself never did? |
| Rule | A suit for declaration must be filed within six years of the denial of rights (Article 120). A fraud-based claim gets three years from knowledge of the fraud (Article 95 with section 18). Heirs cannot revive a right their predecessor let lapse. Settlement-law orders must be challenged before settlement forums. |
| Analysis | The sister knew about the mutation from 1952 but stayed silent until her death in 1988. Her heirs waited another 21 years. Their claim that her share of income was being paid rested on hearsay. The mutation had also been made by a rehabilitation officer, which put it outside the civil court’s reach. |
| Conclusion | The suit was time-barred and the civil court had no jurisdiction. The appellate decree was set aside and the suit was dismissed. |
The Family Story: A 1947 Death and a 1952 Mutation
Karam Bakhsh died in India before Partition, leaving two sons, Abdul Ghafoor and Majeed, and a daughter, Ghafooran Bibi. Under the custom of the time, his land in Mauza Baras, India, passed to the elder son, Abdul Ghafoor.
Abdul Ghafoor died in the riots during migration to Pakistan in 1947. He had no children. He left behind his widow (Mst. Sifta), his brother Majeed and his sister Ghafooran Bibi. A claim for the land he left in India was filed with the Settlement and Rehabilitation authorities under the Pakistan Rehabilitation Ordinance, 1948.
On 30 October 1952, the Assistant Rehabilitation Commissioner sanctioned Mutation No. 01. Land in Mauza Thatha Gulab Singh, Tehsil Kamoke, District Gujranwala, was given to Majeed (3/4 share) and the widow Sifta (1/4 share). Ghafooran Bibi’s name was not in the mutation at all.
At that time Ghafooran Bibi was 50 to 55 years old. She lived until 1988, but she never challenged the mutation. Majeed died on 16 February 1985, and the land passed to his children through later mutations.

How the Case Moved From Court to Court
On 13 June 2009, Ghafooran Bibi’s legal heirs filed a suit in the civil court. They asked for a declaration, cancellation of the 1952 mutation and all later mutations, possession of the land and a permanent injunction.
The case then travelled for 16 years:
- 10 November 2013: The trial court dismissed the suit for lack of jurisdiction.
- 12 November 2015: The Lahore High Court (RFA No. 133 of 2013) sent the case back for findings on every issue, including the effect of the 1975 Repeal Act.
- 30 January 2017: The trial court dismissed the suit again, this time as time-barred.
- 22 February 2020: The Additional District Judge, Kamoke, partly reversed that judgment and decreed the suit.
- 18 June 2025: The Lahore High Court allowed the second appeal and dismissed the suit.
What Each Side Argued
The heirs of Majeed and Sifta (the appellants) raised three objections. The civil court had no jurisdiction because the mutation was made under settlement laws. The suit was time-barred by 56 years and 8 months. And the plaintiffs had no locus standi or cause of action, because Ghafooran Bibi herself never complained.
Ghafooran Bibi’s heirs (the respondents) framed it as a pure inheritance claim. Their plaint said Majeed’s family kept paying her a small share of the land’s income, so the right to sue arose only when those payments stopped.
The Evidence That Sank the Claim
Evidence decided this case more than argument did. Only one legal heir of Ghafooran Bibi, PW-3, came to the witness box. He admitted that he was speaking on the basis of hearsay. He also admitted, more than once, that Ghafooran Bibi knew about the mutation and had told him about it in 1952.
The other witnesses were not her legal heirs and lived far from her village. One was 7 or 8 years old when Abdul Ghafoor died; another was 11 or 12 when the mutation was sanctioned. None could prove that any share of income was ever paid.
The court also noted that pleadings are not evidence, and this plaint was never signed or verified by Ghafooran Bibi herself. The story of “payments” was never proved.
The Law Behind the Decision

Four sets of rules shape limitation in inheritance cases in Pakistan, and all of them mattered here.
Limitation Act, 1908. Under the Limitation Act, 1908, Article 120 is the “catch-all” article. It gives six years to file a suit that has no specific period elsewhere in the First Schedule. A suit for declaration of ownership under section 42 of the Specific Relief Act, 1877 falls under it.
Article 95 and section 18. A suit based on fraud must be filed within three years of learning about the fraud. Section 18 delays the start of limitation only when fraud kept a person from knowing about their right. The person must plead the fraud with full details and the date of knowledge, and then prove it.
Shariat Act, 1948. The West Pakistan Muslim Personal Law (Shariat) Application Act was promulgated on 15 March 1948. After that date, Muslim inheritance had to follow Islamic law, not custom.
Settlement laws. Rehabilitation and settlement laws gave special officers the power to decide refugee land claims, including questions of inheritance. Civil courts were barred from questioning their orders.
Second appeal. Under section 100 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, the High Court can step in when the lower appellate court misreads evidence or the law.
How the High Court Answered Three Key Questions
Did Islamic Law or Custom Govern the Inheritance?
Abdul Ghafoor died in 1947, before the Shariat Act, so the appellants argued that custom applied and Ghafooran Bibi was rightly left out. The court disagreed. Relying on the Supreme Court’s five-member bench in Ghulam Haider v. Murad (PLD 2012 SC 501), it held that the heirs formally acquired the land only through the 1952 mutation, after 15 March 1948. So Islamic law applied.
The court added a sharp point. If custom had really applied, women would have been excluded, and the widow Sifta would not have received any land either. On this question, the lower courts’ findings were upheld.
Could a Civil Court Hear a Settlement-Law Dispute?
No. The mutation was sanctioned by a rehabilitation officer under the settlement laws. The Supreme Court has held in cases such as Ahmad Din v. Muhammad Shafi (PLD 1971 SC 762) and Mst. Zainab v. Mst. Raji (PLD 1960 SC 229) that such inheritance questions were for the settlement authorities alone.
Those laws were repealed in 1975, but under Nazeer Ahmad v. Ghulam Mehdi (1988 SCMR 824) the bar on civil courts survives for orders passed while they were in force. A party cannot skip a special remedy and go straight to the civil court. Both lower courts had missed this.
Can an “Inheritance” Label Beat Limitation?

This is the heart of the judgment. The jurisdiction point alone could end the case, but the court decided limitation too, to close the dispute for good.
The court said, in paragraph 20, that “a claim of inheritance must cross the bridge of limitation, waiver and acquiescence.” It relied on a line of Supreme Court cases:
- Muhammad Rustam (2013 SCMR 299): if the deprived heir never challenged a mutation in his lifetime, his heirs cannot challenge it later.
- Mst. Grana (PLD 2014 SC 167): not every inheritance case is free from limitation; conduct matters.
- Atta Muhammad (2007 SCMR 1446): a 46-year delay could not be ignored.
- Salamat Ali (PLD 2022 SC 353): fraud under section 18 must be pleaded with details and the date of knowledge, then proved.
- Saadat Khan (PLD 2023 SC 362): a sister’s suit against her brother falls under Article 120, and the six years run from his denial of her rights.
The Final Decision
The High Court answered all three questions:
- The Shariat Act applied when the 1952 mutation was sanctioned.
- The civil court had no jurisdiction over this suit.
- The suit was in any case time-barred under Articles 95 and 120 of the First Schedule, read with section 18 of the Limitation Act, 1908.
The court held that the first appellate court’s judgment was the result of misreading and non-reading of evidence. The second appeal was allowed, the 2020 judgment was set aside and the heirs’ suit was dismissed, with no order as to costs.
What the Court Did and Did Not Decide
What it decided: Heirs cannot use an inheritance label to revive a claim their predecessor knowingly left alone for decades. A claimant must first show the claim is not hit by waiver and acquiescence. Settlement-law mutations had to be challenged before settlement forums.
What it did not decide: The court did not say that every inheritance claim expires after six years. It did not rule against women’s inheritance rights. In fact, it warned that long trials in time-barred suits are “counterproductive for genuine and bona fide claims of female heirs” (para 20). It also explained why Supreme Court cases such as Shabla (2020 SCMR 352) and Mohammad Boota v. Mst. Fatima (2023 SCMR 1901) went the other way. In those cases, the women challenged the mutation in their own lifetime and proved concealment or proved that their share of income was being paid.
Does a Newer Supreme Court Ruling Change the Picture?
In June 2026, a two-member Supreme Court bench decided Noor Muhammad v. Ghulam Haider (C.P.L.A. No. 1103-L of 2016). It restored the shares of a widow and her daughters after a dispute that ran for about 71 years. The court held that women cannot lose their inheritance on the basis of an oral gift (hiba) that is not strictly proved. An old mutation, long possession or later revenue entries are not proof of a gift on their own.
Media reports say the court accepted that limitation may matter in some cases, but held that such claims should not be thrown out merely for delay or technical objections. Some lawyers read this as a softer approach to limitation in inheritance cases in Pakistan than PLD 2026 Lahore 146.
The facts were very different. Noor Muhammad was about women deprived through an unproved gift. PLD 2026 Lahore 146 was about heirs of a woman who knew of the mutation for 36 years, never challenged it, and whose heirs waited 21 more years. Both rulings agree on one thing: the facts and the evidence decide the outcome. If your case involves a disputed gift, read our guide on gift deed law in Pakistan.
Limitation in Inheritance Cases in Pakistan: Which Side Are You On?

In Syed Kausar Ali Shah v. Syed Farhat Hussain Shah (2022 SCMR 1558), the Supreme Court drew a clear line between two kinds of heirs. The High Court relied on it in this case.
Category A: the heir who acts. You find out that your name is missing from the mutation, or your brother refuses your share, and you take action quickly. Courts generally look kindly on such heirs, especially women.
Category B: the heir who sits idle. You know about the old entries but stay silent for years. You come to court only after the land is sold or third parties have built on it. To win, you must show that you did not know about the deprivation, give strong reasons for your silence, and show that the buyer knew about your share or acted in collusion with the seller.
Ghafooran Bibi’s heirs fell in the second category. Ask yourself honestly where you stand today. For women’s rights in particular, see our section on women’s inheritance rights.
Evidence to Keep and Next Steps Before Time Runs Out

Limitation in inheritance cases in Pakistan usually turns on dates and proof. Start collecting these today:
- Certified copies of the mutation (intiqal) and the record of rights (jamabandi or fard) for every relevant year.
- The date you first learnt that your name was missing, and how you learnt it. Write it down with names of people present.
- Proof of any denial, such as a refusal by a brother, a legal notice, or a sale of the land.
- Proof of share income, such as bank transfers, receipts or crop-share records. Hearsay witnesses will not help.
- Proof of concealment, if someone hid the mutation from you. A vague fraud claim fails; dates and details win.
- Details of later buyers, because the law protects a genuine buyer who paid value in good faith.
Next steps:
- Act within six years of the date your rights were clearly denied. Do not wait for verbal promises.
- Choose the right forum. Land that came through settlement or rehabilitation authorities may need a special forum, not an ordinary civil suit.
- Women in Punjab can also complain to the Ombudsperson under the Punjab Enforcement of Women’s Property Rights Act, 2021.
- Criminal remedy: depriving a woman of her inheritance by deceitful or illegal means is an offence under section 498-A PPC, punishable with 5 to 10 years’ imprisonment, a fine of Rs1 million, or both.
- Plan the division early. Our guides on inheritance disputes in Pakistan and partition of inherited land explain the next stage.
Common mistakes: believing “inheritance has no limitation,” trusting family promises for years, suing in the wrong forum, vague fraud claims and hearsay witnesses.
FAQs About Limitation in Inheritance Cases in Pakistan
1. Is there any limitation in inheritance cases in Pakistan?
Yes. Courts protect inheritance rights strongly, but limitation is not ignored. Under Article 120 of the Limitation Act, 1908, a declaration suit for an inheritance share generally has six years from when the right to sue arises. Courts also check waiver and acquiescence, so your facts decide the answer.
2. What is the time limit to challenge an inheritance mutation?
For a declaration suit, the usual period is six years under Article 120, counted from when your right to sue accrued. If you claim the mutation was made or hidden through fraud, Article 95 gives three years from when you learnt of the fraud, and section 18 can delay the start date. You must plead and prove the fraud with clear details.
3. Can a sister claim her share many years after her father’s death?
Sometimes, yes. In Saadat Khan (PLD 2023 SC 362), the Supreme Court said the six years run from when the brother actually denies her rights, not simply from the father’s death. Women who were kept in the dark, or who received a share of income until it stopped, have won late claims. Long, knowing silence can still defeat a claim.
4. Can children challenge a mutation their mother never challenged?
It is very difficult. In PLD 2026 Lahore 146, the High Court held that heirs claim only through their predecessor. If the mother knew of the mutation and let her right lapse, that binds her children too, as the Supreme Court also held in Muhammad Rustam (2013 SCMR 299). There is no fresh six years.
5. Does PLD 2026 Lahore 146 mean old claims are always lost?
No. The judgment turned on strong facts: the sister knew of the mutation from 1952, stayed silent for 36 years, and her heirs waited another 21 years with hearsay evidence. The court itself explained why cases with concealment, minority or proven share payments were decided differently. A newer Supreme Court ruling, Noor Muhammad (2026), also shows that unproved gifts cannot defeat women’s shares.
6. When does the six-year period actually start?
It starts when your right to sue accrues, which under section 42 of the Specific Relief Act is when someone denies your right or threatens to. An actual denial, such as a brother refusing your share or selling the land as his own, starts the clock. A fresh threat can give a fresh cause of action.
7. What evidence helps beat a limitation objection?
Documents with dates are your strongest tools. Keep certified copies of mutations and jamabandi, proof of when you first learnt of the wrong entry, and proof of any share income you received. Witnesses should have direct knowledge, not hearsay. If you allege fraud, give full particulars and your date of knowledge in the plaint, as required by Order VI Rule 4 CPC.
8. Where can a woman in Punjab complain if she is denied inheritance?
She can file a civil suit for declaration and possession. She can also file a complaint with the Ombudsperson Punjab under the Punjab Enforcement of Women’s Property Rights Act, 2021, which offers a faster route for women deprived of ownership or possession. Depriving a woman of inheritance by deceitful or illegal means is also a crime under section 498-A PPC.
Conclusion: Your Share Is Real, but the Clock Is Real Too
PLD 2026 Lahore 146 does not take away anyone’s share under Islamic law. The court accepted that Islamic law, not custom, governed the 1952 mutation, a finding that favoured Ghafooran Bibi’s side. Yet her heirs lost, because she stayed silent for 36 years, they waited 21 more, and their evidence was weak.
The message of limitation in inheritance cases in Pakistan is simple. Do not treat your share as something that can wait forever. Check the record, note your dates, keep your proof and act soon after your rights are denied. For more rulings on this topic, browse our limitation in inheritance judgments.
Disclaimer: This article is for legal awareness only and is not legal advice. Every inheritance case depends on its own facts, documents and evidence. For your specific matter, consult a qualified lawyer.