
A late-night WhatsApp message from your boss. A reminder of the “favours” he did in your service matters. A quiet warning that your appointment can be cancelled if you say no. Many working women in Pakistan know this fear, and many of them stay silent.
Before you decide that nothing can be done, read this Harassment Complaint Pakistan guide. It is built on a Lahore High Court judgment in which a supervisor lost his job, even though one serious alleged incident happened at the woman’s home, not inside the office.
In PLD 2026 Lahore 303, the officer argued that a house is not a workplace, that a criminal case was already pending and that the WhatsApp screenshots were never forensically checked. The Court rejected every one of these pleas. Below you will find what the Court decided, which forum to approach, the deadlines, the evidence to save and the mistakes that quietly ruin genuine cases.
Table of Contents
Judgment at a Glance: PLD 2026 Lahore 303
| Point | Detail |
|---|---|
| Case title | Umer Shehzad v. Ombudsperson (Mohtasib) Punjab and others |
| Citation | PLD 2026 Lahore 303 |
| Court and bench | Lahore High Court, single bench of Justice Raheel Kamran |
| Case number | Writ Petition No. 25636 of 2025 |
| Date of decision | 15 October 2025 |
| Law involved | Protection Against Harassment of Women at the Workplace Act, 2010 (as adapted for Punjab), Sections 2(h), 2(n) and 8; Punjab Rules of 2013, Rules 5 and 10; Articles 13 and 199 of the Constitution |
| Complainant | An ad hoc teacher at a government girls’ vocational institute in Jhang (Respondent No. 3) |
| Accused | Her supervisory officer, posted as DM at the same institute |
| Ombudsperson Punjab | 16 February 2024: guilty of harassment; major penalty of removal from service |
| Governor of Punjab | 20 March 2025: representation dismissed |
| Result in one line | Writ petition dismissed; the finding of harassment and removal from service stand |
IRAC Summary: What the Lahore High Court Decided
| IRAC | In simple words |
|---|---|
| Issue | Could the Ombudsperson Punjab decide the complaint when one alleged incident happened at the complainant’s home, a criminal case on the same facts was pending and the WhatsApp messages had no forensic report? |
| Rule | Section 2(n) treats as a workplace “any situation that is linked to official work or official activity outside the office”. The Code of Conduct in the Schedule counts abuse of authority by a supervisor as harassment. Section 8(1) lets an employee go straight to the Ombudsperson. |
| Analysis | The officer was her supervisor and allegedly used threats about her appointment. He never challenged the WhatsApp messages during the inquiry and even admitted phone contact. The Ombudsperson decides on preponderance of probabilities, not on criminal rules of evidence. |
| Conclusion | A real workplace nexus existed, the criminal case was no bar, and the verification defect in the complaint was curable. The Court found nothing perverse or illegal and dismissed the petition. |
What Happened in the Jhang Harassment Case?
The complainant was an ad hoc teacher at the Government Girls Vocational Institute, Satellite Town, Jhang. The petitioner was posted at the same institute as DM and was her supervisory officer. That hierarchy sits at the centre of the whole case.
In her complaint before the Ombudsperson Punjab, she alleged that he cast indecent glances at her, sent her inappropriate messages and kept trying to start an illicit relationship. She said he reminded her of favours he had done in her service matters, demanded something in return and threatened to cancel her appointment orders if she refused.
She further alleged that on the night between 14 and 15 September 2022 he came to her residence, pretended to deliver an application and a letter, forced his way in and attempted to sexually assault her. She called Rescue-15, he fled, and two witnesses and the police reached the spot. She said the threats continued afterwards.
These were allegations. The officer denied them in his written defence. After recording evidence from both sides, the Ombudsperson held him guilty of harassment under Section 2(h) on 16 February 2024 and imposed the major penalty of removal from service. The Governor of Punjab dismissed his representation on 20 March 2025, so he filed a writ petition in the Lahore High Court.
What Each Side Argued Before the Court
The officer’s defence was that the complaint grew out of a grudge. He said the complainant lived in an official quarter allotted to her brother, a TEVTA employee, and that the allotment was cancelled under his orders. He also said her daily-wage service under him was later terminated, which added to her resentment.
| Question | Officer (petitioner) | Complainant and Punjab Government |
|---|---|---|
| Jurisdiction | The alleged incident happened at her residence, which is not a workplace | The incident had a direct nexus with the working relationship, so Section 2(n) applied |
| Criminal case | A criminal case on the same facts was pending, so parallel proceedings were barred | Criminal and workplace proceedings work in separate legal fields |
| WhatsApp messages | Screenshots were relied on without forensic authentication | Messages and witness statements were part of the evidence the officer never rebutted |
| Witnesses | Not eye-witnesses and not independently corroborated | The officer had full opportunity to defend himself and produced no cogent rebuttal |
| The complaint itself | Not verified under Rule 5(3) and supporting material not annexed under Rule 5(2) | All procedural formalities were observed |
| Penalty | Removal from service was arbitrary, disproportionate and stigmatising | The Ombudsperson passed a reasoned order and the Governor independently found no illegality |
The Assistant Advocate General Punjab supported both decisions. The Court also heard an amicus curiae, who said a workplace includes conduct that grows out of workplace authority, such as messaging a subordinate or visiting her residence in connection with employment.
How the Court Judged the WhatsApp Evidence
The officer’s strongest technical point was that the WhatsApp screenshots had no forensic report. The Court looked at how he had dealt with those messages during the inquiry, and the answer hurt his case badly.
- In his written defence he did not categorically deny the allegations, and he never denied that WhatsApp communication existed.
- He claimed the complainant had threatened him through her mobile phone, which indirectly admitted that the two were in contact.
- During cross-examination he did not question the authenticity of the messages and never applied for forensic verification.
- His denial first appeared before the Governor and then the High Court. The Court called it “an afterthought, lacking bona fides” (para 9).
The Court also noted that the messages fitted the pattern alleged, including references to service-related consequences. Taken together, these factors were enough under the standard of preponderance of probabilities, without formal forensic certification (para 12).
The officer also tried to question the complainant’s character and her personal circumstances. The Court found these were speculative assertions without concrete evidence, and they did not break the link between his conduct and his supervisory power (para 13).

The Law Behind a Harassment Complaint Pakistan Case
Pakistan’s workplace harassment law began as the federal Protection Against Harassment of Women at the Workplace Act, 2010. After the 18th Amendment, Punjab adapted it through the Punjab Protection Against Harassment of Women at the Workplace (Amendment) Act, 2012. That Punjab version is the law the Lahore High Court applied in this case.
Key Definitions in the Punjab Law
- Complainant: a woman or man who complains to the Ombudsperson or the Inquiry Committee after facing harassment.
- Employee: a regular or contractual worker paid daily, weekly, monthly or hourly, including interns and apprentices.
- Harassment, Section 2(h): unwelcome sexual advances, requests for sexual favours, sexual verbal or written communication, physical conduct of a sexual nature or sexually demeaning attitudes that interfere with work or create an intimidating, hostile or offensive environment. Punishing someone for refusing is also covered.
- Workplace, Section 2(n): the place where the employer operates, including any situation linked to official work or official activity outside the office.
The Code of Conduct in the Schedule names three forms of harassment: abuse of authority, a hostile environment and retaliation. Abuse of authority means a person in authority, such as a supervisor, demanding sexual favours in exchange for job benefits like pay, promotion, training, transfer or the job itself. That was the heart of this case.
Two Forums, One Choice
Section 8(1) gives every employee a choice. She can complain to her organisation’s Inquiry Committee or go directly to the Ombudsperson (Mohtasib). There is no rule that she must first approach HR. The complainant here chose the Ombudsperson Punjab, and the Court confirmed she was entitled to do so.
The Ombudsperson must issue a show-cause notice within 3 days of receiving the complaint, and the accused must file a written defence within 5 days. If he fails without reasonable cause, the case may proceed ex parte. Under Rule 10 of the Punjab Rules of 2013, the parties get a personal hearing, witnesses can be summoned, and the decision must give reasons.

Federal Law and Punjab Law Are Not the Same
The federal Act was widely amended in 2022, but the Punjab text the Court applied did not take those amendments on board. Copying a federal definition into a Punjab complaint can therefore weaken it. Read the federal Act as amended in 2022 side by side with the Punjab version.
| Point | Punjab law (applied in this case) | Federal law after the 2022 amendment |
|---|---|---|
| Who can complain | A woman or man | Any person, including a former employee, and a parent or guardian for a minor |
| Who is an employee | Regular or contractual workers, interns and apprentices | Also gig, part-time and freelance workers, students, trainees, domestic and home-based workers, and more |
| What is harassment | Unwelcome sexual conduct, sexual communication, abuse of authority | Also stalking, cyberstalking and gender-based discrimination that may or may not be sexual |
| Ombudsperson’s decision | As expeditiously as possible (Rule 10(7)) | Within 90 days |
| Challenge to Ombudsperson’s order | Representation to the Governor within 30 days; Governor’s decision final | Representation to the President or Governor within 30 days, decided within 90 days |
| Extra major penalty | Not in the Punjab list | Suspension or cancellation of a professional licence |
As a rule of thumb, Punjab government offices and private organisations in Punjab come under the Ombudsperson Punjab, while federal bodies come under the Federal Ombudsperson (FOSPAH). If your employer’s status is unclear, settle that question first. You can read more guides in our women harassment section.
7 Rules the Lahore High Court Laid Down

The judgment answers questions that come up in almost every workplace harassment case. Here is the Court’s reasoning, rule by rule, in plain words.
1. Harassment Is Not Limited to Office Walls
The Court read Section 2(n) together with the Code of Conduct and held that the law does not stop at the office building. In its words, “The statutory emphasis, therefore, is not on geography alone” (para 10). What matters is the link between the conduct and the job, especially where a supervisor’s power is misused.
The alleged night visit could not be viewed in isolation. Prima facie, it looked like the continuation of a pattern that had already shown itself through workplace-linked messages and misuse of supervisory authority. The Court went further: even if the home incident were set aside, the admitted supervisory relationship and the uncontroverted messages were enough to attract the Act (para 12).
2. A Purely Private Dispute Is Still Outside the Law
This protection is not unlimited. The Act does not turn every personal quarrel between two colleagues into workplace harassment. The Ombudsperson’s jurisdiction arises only where the conduct grows out of, is made easier by, or is tied up with the employment relationship, or where power from the office is used to pressure someone (para 11).
The Court’s test is simple: was the job merely in the background, or was it the source of the power behind the conduct? Here the parties were not equals. Their relationship rested on hierarchy and dependence, and the threats concerned her appointment, which he could influence (para 12).
3. Unchallenged WhatsApp Messages Can Prove Harassment
Digital evidence usually invites scrutiny. Here the messages carried weight because the officer never challenged their existence, content or context during the inquiry, admitted being in contact and never asked for a forensic test. The Court relied on them without a forensic certificate (para 12). This is not a free pass for every screenshot: an accused who believes messages are fake must object at the right stage.
4. Late Reporting Is Not Consent
Relying on the Supreme Court in Uzma Naveed Chaudhary v. Federation of Pakistan (PLD 2022 SC 783), the Court recognised that women often delay reporting harassment out of concern for dignity, family honour and social stigma. Their initial silence cannot be treated as waiver, acquiescence or estoppel once they find the courage to complain (para 13).
5. A Pending Criminal Case Does Not Stop the Ombudsperson
An FIR and a private complaint about the same incident were pending, and the officer called the inquiry double jeopardy. The Court disagreed. Article 13 of the Constitution and Section 403 of the Code of Criminal Procedure only bar repeated criminal trials or punishments. An inquiry under the 2010 Act is a separate disciplinary process that leads to service penalties, so both can run side by side. The Court relied on Raja Tanveer Safdar v. Mrs. Tehmina Yasmeen (2024 PLC (C.S.) 957) (para 14).
6. The Ombudsperson Is Not a Criminal Court
Neither the Act nor the Rules require the Ombudsperson to follow the Code of Civil Procedure, the Code of Criminal Procedure or the strict evidence rules of the Qanun-e-Shahadat Order, 1984. Rule 10(6) allows the Ombudsperson to adopt whatever procedure is needed for a just decision, while still following natural justice.
The standard of proof is the civil one, preponderance of probabilities, and not proof beyond reasonable doubt. Simply put, the forum asks which version is more likely true on the whole record. The Court relied on Nadia Naz v. President of Pakistan (PLD 2023 SC 588) (para 15).
7. A Defect in the Complaint Form Is Curable
The officer said the complaint was not verified under Rule 5(3) and lacked annexures under Rule 5(2). The Court held that Rule 5 describes the ideal form of a complaint but makes no omission fatal. Verification is directory, not mandatory, and Rule 5(4) allows amendment at any stage. Since the officer received the complaint, defended himself, had a hearing and showed no prejudice, the complaint stood (para 16).
Final Decision of the Lahore High Court
The Court first explained its own limits. In a writ petition under Article 199, the High Court acts in a supervisory role. It does not sit as a court of second appeal to reweigh evidence, and it interferes only where findings are perverse, contrary to law or based on no evidence at all (para 8).
Tested on that standard, the Ombudsperson’s finding of guilt, affirmed by the Governor, was a reasonable and logical conclusion from the record (para 17). The findings suffered from no jurisdictional defect or legal infirmity, so the petition was dismissed (para 18). The removal from service stands. More rulings like this one are collected in our Lahore High Court judgments section.
What the Court Did Not Decide
Anyone relying on this ruling in a Harassment Complaint Pakistan matter should also know its limits:
- It did not decide the criminal case. The FIR and private complaint about the alleged night incident stay with the criminal courts, where proof beyond reasonable doubt is required.
- It did not say every incident at home is workplace harassment. Jurisdiction came from the supervisory relationship and job-related threats, not from the address.
- It did not say screenshots never need forensic checks. The messages were accepted because they were never properly challenged during the inquiry.
- It did not separately reweigh the penalty. The plea that removal was too harsh failed because the Court found no ground to interfere at all.
- It applied the Punjab law. The judgment binds forums under the Punjab law. Elsewhere it can be cited as persuasive, but federal cases and other provinces follow their own statutes.
What This Judgment Means for Working Women and Employers
For employees: Misuse of power does not become legal because it happens after office hours, on WhatsApp or at your door. If your boss uses your appointment, salary, transfer or contract as leverage, that link to your job can bring the matter under the Act. You can go directly to the Ombudsperson, and a delay caused by fear is not the end of your case.
For the accused: Technical objections alone rarely save a case. Answer each allegation specifically, challenge any fake digital material at the first stage, ask for forensic examination if you genuinely need it and cross-examine properly. Attacks on the complainant’s character without proof did not help the officer here.
For employers: Section 11 of the Punjab law requires every covered employer to adopt the Code of Conduct, form a three-member Inquiry Committee with at least one woman and designate a competent authority. The Code must be displayed in English and in a language most staff understand. An employer who fails can be fined between Rs. 25,000 and Rs. 100,000 on a complaint to the Ombudsperson.
The Code also tells employers to separate the parties during an inquiry where possible and to watch evaluations, duties and reporting lines so that the complainant is not punished for speaking up. Section 4 requires counselling or medical treatment and extra medical leave if the complainant is traumatised.
How to File a Harassment Complaint in Pakistan: Step by Step
A strong complaint is not a long one. It is specific, dated and clearly tied to your job. These eight steps follow the order in which most Harassment Complaint Pakistan cases actually unfold.
Step 1: Write a Dated Record While Memory Is Fresh
Keep a private diary of every incident: date, approximate time, place, exact words or acts, and who saw or heard anything. Note every threat about your appointment, salary, transfer, promotion or contract. Also write down when you first told someone and what happened after you objected. A dated record turns scattered events into a pattern the forum can follow.
Step 2: Save the Original Digital Evidence
Export the complete WhatsApp chat, not one cropped screenshot. Keep voice notes, call logs, emails, office group messages and the phone itself. Make a secure backup before you block, delete or change anything. Never edit a single message, because tampered evidence can destroy an honest case.
Step 3: Spell Out the Link With Your Job
This judgment shows that the workplace link can matter as much as the messages. Ask yourself: Is the accused my supervisor? Can he affect my appointment, transfer, duties or evaluation? Did he mention favours in my service file? Did work-related contact continue after hours? Write those answers into your complaint.

Step 4: Choose the Right Forum
- Punjab offices and organisations: complain to your organisation’s Inquiry Committee or directly to the Ombudsperson Punjab under Section 8(1). The Office of the Ombudsperson Punjab is at 197-Abubakar Block, Garden Town, Lahore. After a long vacancy, a new Ombudsperson Punjab took charge in April 2026.
- Federal organisations: the Federal Ombudsperson (FOSPAH) accepts complaints online, by post or in person, and also takes complaints where an Inquiry Committee does not exist or is not working. Its helpline is 03444 367 367 and its email is [email protected], as listed in FOSPAH’s official complaint guide.
Step 5: Draft a Clear, Signed Complaint
Rule 5 of the Punjab Rules asks for a full statement of facts, names of witnesses and every supporting document, audio or video attached. The complainant must verify the contents as true and sign or thumb-mark the complaint. A missed verification is curable, as this case shows, but a careful complaint saves months of argument.
Step 6: Know the Timeline After Filing
| Stage | Ombudsperson Punjab | Inquiry Committee |
|---|---|---|
| Notice to the accused | Show-cause notice within 3 days | Charges within 3 days |
| Written defence | Within 5 days | Within 7 days |
| Findings | Reasoned decision, as expeditiously as possible | Within 30 days of starting the inquiry |
| Penalty | Competent authority implements within 30 days | Competent authority imposes it within 1 week |
| Challenge | Representation to the Governor within 30 days | Appeal to the Ombudsperson within 30 days |
Under the federal law, the Ombudsperson must decide within 90 days, and a representation to the President must be filed within 30 days. The Act sets no fixed deadline for filing the first complaint, but explain any delay. Missing a 30-day appeal or representation deadline can cost you the right to challenge an order.
Step 7: Protect Yourself From Retaliation
During an inquiry, no adverse action may be taken against the complainant or witnesses, and the employer must not create a hostile environment to pressure her. Evidence is kept confidential, and each side may bring a CBA representative, a friend or a colleague. Record any sudden transfer, bad evaluation, isolation or pressure to withdraw, and report it to the forum.
Step 8: Use the Criminal and Cyber Routes Where Needed
An assault, trespass or threat can also be a crime. In an emergency, call 15. Workplace proceedings and a criminal case can run side by side, as this judgment confirms. If the harassment is mainly online, such as fake profiles, blackmail or cyberstalking with no job link, the National Cyber Crime Investigation Agency (NCCIA) handles complaints under PECA 2016 through its helpline 1799.
In Punjab, the Punjab Women’s Helpline 1043 runs round the clock with women call agents and legal advisers. It can guide you, but a helpline call is not a formal complaint before the Ombudsperson.
Harassment Complaint Pakistan Evidence Checklist
Quality beats quantity. A forum is persuaded by a connected story, not by a pile of unexplained screenshots.
| Evidence | Why it helps |
|---|---|
| Full WhatsApp export and the original phone | Shows exact words, dates and context, and protects authenticity |
| Call logs and voice notes | Support the pattern of contact |
| Appointment letter, contract or ad hoc order | Proves you are an employee under the Act |
| Office order or reporting line | Shows the accused’s supervisory power over you |
| Transfer, evaluation or termination papers | Can show leverage before the complaint or retaliation after it |
| Earlier complaint to HR or a senior officer | Shows you reported the conduct |
| Names of witnesses | People who saw, heard or were told at the time |
| Rescue-15, police or medical record | Supports a prompt report of a serious incident |
| Dated incident diary | Links separate events into one pattern |
| Messages received after you complained | May show pressure to withdraw |
Common Mistakes That Weaken a Genuine Complaint
- Using the wrong law or forum. Federal definitions copied into a Punjab complaint, or a complaint sent to an office with no jurisdiction, waste precious months.
- Writing general accusations. “He harasses me” without dates, words and places gives the accused easy room to deny.
- Keeping only one cropped screenshot. Deleted chats and missing context invite doubts about authenticity.
- Forgetting the job link. If you do not explain how his position gave him power over you, he will call it a private dispute.
- Missing the 30-day window. Appeals and representations have short deadlines, so note the date of every order.
- Adding facts that did not happen. Exaggeration damages credibility, and the law allows action against a complainant whose false allegations were made in bad faith.

Harassment Complaint Pakistan: Frequently Asked Questions
Where can I file a workplace harassment complaint in Pakistan?
You can file it with your organisation’s Inquiry Committee or go straight to the Ombudsperson. In Punjab, Section 8(1) of the provincial law gives you that choice, and PLD 2026 Lahore 303 confirmed it. Federal employees approach the Federal Ombudsperson (FOSPAH), which accepts complaints online, by post or in person. Other provinces have their own Ombudspersons under their own versions of the law.
Can a man file a workplace harassment complaint?
Yes. The Punjab law defines a complainant as a woman or man. The federal law, after the 2022 amendment, goes further and allows any person to complain, including a former employee. The Ombudsperson Punjab has also publicly said that men facing harassment can approach her office. What matters is that the conduct falls within the definition of harassment and the right forum is chosen.
Does harassment outside the office count as workplace harassment?
Yes, if it is genuinely linked to the job. In PLD 2026 Lahore 303 the Lahore High Court held that the law is not limited to office walls. Conduct at a home, on the phone or after hours can be covered when a supervisor uses his position to pressure an employee. A purely private dispute between colleagues, with no job link, remains outside the Act.
Can WhatsApp messages prove workplace harassment?
They can. In this case, the Court relied on WhatsApp messages without a forensic report because the accused never challenged them during the inquiry and admitted phone contact. Their weight depends on authenticity, context and how the other side responds. Keep the complete chat and the original phone, and never edit anything you plan to submit.
Is there a time limit to file a harassment complaint?
The Act does not fix a deadline for filing the first complaint, and the Court held that initial silence out of fear or stigma is not consent. Even so, report as early as you safely can and explain any delay in your complaint. Later stages have strict limits: appeals and representations must usually be filed within 30 days.
Can I complain to the Ombudsperson while a criminal case is pending?
Yes. The Court held that a criminal case does not oust or suspend the Ombudsperson’s jurisdiction. The criminal court decides guilt and punishment for an offence, while the Ombudsperson deals with workplace misconduct and service penalties. The double jeopardy protection in Article 13 applies to repeated criminal trials, not to a disciplinary inquiry running alongside one.
What penalties can the Ombudsperson impose for harassment?
Under the Punjab law, minor penalties include censure, withholding promotion or increment for a period and recovering compensation from the harasser’s pay. Major penalties include reduction to a lower post, compulsory retirement, removal from service, dismissal and a fine, part of which can compensate the complainant. In this case, the officer received the major penalty of removal from service.
What can I do if I disagree with the Ombudsperson’s decision?
In Punjab, either party can make a representation to the Governor within 30 days, and the Governor’s decision is final under the Act. After that, a writ petition in the High Court is possible, but as this case shows, the High Court only checks for perversity, illegality or lack of evidence. It does not rehear the whole case.
Conclusion: Power Does Not End at the Office Door
A boss’s power does not switch off at closing time, and neither does the law. PLD 2026 Lahore 303 tells every supervisor in Punjab that threats over an employee’s appointment, whether sent on WhatsApp or carried to her door, can end in removal from service. It also reminds complainants that the Act protects job-linked abuse, not every personal quarrel.
If you are preparing a Harassment Complaint Pakistan file, start quietly and carefully. Keep a dated record, save the complete chats, explain how his position gave him power over you, choose the right forum and watch every 30-day deadline. For more on your legal protections, read our guides on women’s rights in Pakistan and our landmark judgments.
Disclaimer
This article is for legal awareness only and is not legal advice. Every case depends on its own facts, documents, evidence and the law that applies to your employer. For your specific matter, especially one involving violence, criminal allegations or termination, consult a qualified lawyer.